Northern California Bankruptcy Lawyer

On The Bankruptcy Soapbox

The Soap Box

Choosing Between Bankruptcy Chapters

By

choose bankruptcy chapter

Seven or Thirteen?

13 or 7?

When you have a choice, how do you decide which chapter of bankruptcy works best?

Usually, the choice is driven by the scope of the discharge and the kind of debts you have.

More kinds of  debts are dischargeable in Chapter 13 and the automatic stay protects you for the 60 month duration of the case.

So why did the client this week choose to walk out of Chapter 7 with fewer debts discharged than if he’d chosen 13?

It’s all about his  future.  And who will get to share in his growing earning capacity.

Chapter 7 over Chapter 13

On the surface, this client seemed a great candidate for Chapter 13, which is my favorite  bankruptcy chapter.

Some of his debts were only dischargeable in Chapter 13;  in Chapter 7, he’d emerge still owing some debts from a divorce.

So why choose the smaller discharge?

Because his earnings were likely to double or triple over the life of a Chapter 13 case.

If that happened, we anticipated that a Chapter 13 trustee would move to modify his payment plan to pay more to general unsecured creditors.

Credit card debt, which would get nothing in a Chapter 7, might well get a substantial repayment from his increased earnings.

He’d pay fewer dollars paying directly the non dischargeable debt that survives a Chapter 7  than he would paying in a larger slice of his paycheck  to all of his creditors in a Chapter 13 plan.

Chapter 13 after confirmation

Judges approve Chapter 13 plans based on the situation when the bankruptcy case is filed.  The means test looks at recent income.  The liquidation test looks at non exempt assets at filing.

For this client, each of those numbers was modest and a repayment plan would be relatively cheap.

But Chapter 13 involves committing your future income to the supervision of the Chapter 13 trustee.

Now, that supervision is pretty minimal:  it usually means the trustee monitors your tax returns to see in your income has increased.

If there’s a significant increase, the trustee can file a motion with the court proposing increased monthly payments going forward.

The debtor gets to respond with updated expense schedules, and if the parties can’t reach a deal, a judge decides whether payments change.

In the Bay Area, this happens very infrequently.  I’ve seen it less than a half dozen times in 20+ years of doing lots of 13’s.

But it can happen, and for this client, it seemed quite likely that a new job in his usual profession would dramatically increase his income.

Chapter 7 looks at today

If Chapter 13 is a years long process, Chapter 7 is a single event.

The rights of the debtor and the creditors are determined by the situation on the day the case is filed.

If the means test says that Chapter 7 is an option, then the creditors get only what the debtor owns at the filing of the case.

And what the creditors share in is only what’s left after the debtor chooses his exempt property.  Most Chapter 7 cases make no distribution to creditors.

Future income belongs to the debtor.  The Chapter 7 trustee can’t come back a year later and ask for a slice of a larger paycheck.

So, much to my surprise, when we looked at this client’s current situation and his prospects, the more limited discharge was a better deal than Chapter 13.

He’ll get to enjoy a larger share of his future earnings and a fresh start.

More

Cheat sheet for passing the means test

Figuring what you pay in Chapter 13

How to make your divorce bankruptcy-proof

When your ex files bankruptcy

Dividing debts in divorce

 

Ten Debts That Follow You After Bankruptcy

By

debts after bankruptcy

Some debts just follow you out of bankruptcy.

Not many but a few.

These debts continue to be collectible even after a Chapter 7 discharge.  The discharge in Chapter 13 is different and broader:  just another reason to choose Chapter 13.

1.   Family support

Regardless of what it’s called, court ordered payments for support of children or spouses

2.   Recent taxes

Income taxes for tax years  more than three years old, counting from when the return was due

3.   Taxes still assessable

The IRS ability to assess additional tax survives if the tax year was still assessable at filing

4.   Taxes for unfiled years

The clock doesn’t run on tax discharge until an honest return is filed.

5.   Payroll taxes

The trust portion of payroll taxes, federal and state:  that’s what the employer withholds from employee checks

6.   Judgments for drunk driving

Liability for death or personal injury from impaired operation of a vehicle

7.   Debts to spouse or child from divorce

Debts to your own lawyer do get wiped out

8.   Student loans

Unless you file suit in the bankruptcy and prove repayment is an undue hardship

9.   Money borrowed to pay non dischargeable tax

No paying taxes with a loan you want to discharge.

10.  Penalties to governments

This covers fines, penalties and forfeitures that are intended to punish not compensate

Non dischargeable if….

Three additional categories of debts survive bankruptcy only if the affected creditor successfully jumps through some legal hoops in the bankruptcy case.

Debts incurred by fraud; debts for conversion or breach of fiduciary duty; and debts for deliberate injury to person or property require the victim to file suit and prove the operative facts.

There’s a short period for filing a non dischargeability action and the presumptions operate in favor of the debtor.  But if the creditor can establish the bad behavior of the debtor that created the debt, public policy says we don’t want to shelter bad actors.

It’s important to understand that the debt must have been incurred by the bad behavior;  just trying to evade payment of an honestly incurred debt doesn’t make it non dischargeable, in most instances.

Liens survive unless…

How to get rid of liens through bankruptcy

While a bankruptcy discharge wipes out your personal liability for discharged debts, a lien on property you owned when you filed bankruptcy continues to be liable for the debt.  So you aren’t liable but your property can be seized to pay the debt.

Think of your home loan:  your discharge keeps the lender from suing you after bankruptcy for a money judgment, but it doesn’t keep the lender from foreclosing on your house if you don’t pay after bankruptcy..

After bankruptcy, as long as you continue to pay on a secured debt, the creditor is generally happy to take your money and leave you alone.  If you change your mind, or further financial troubles loom, you can walk away from the liened property, losing only the property.

An experienced bankruptcy lawyer can walk you through the bankruptcy discharge and the landscape after your case is over.

More

Interview questions for hiring a bankruptcy lawyer

What to do about tax liens

Reaffirming a car debt

 

Protecting Your Co signor When You Can’t Pay

By

cosigned loans

Cosigning a loan links you and your cosignor together for the life of the debt.

If you get in financial trouble, your troubles are your co signor’s troubles too.

If you can’t pay your debts, the standard bankruptcy discharge will get rid of your debt, but it doesn’t help your co signor.

Even while you are protected in bankruptcy by the automatic stay, keeping collectors at bay, and by the discharge at the end of the case, anyone who cosigned for you is exposed.

But Chapter 13 isn’t the “standard” bankruptcy.  It has a special protection for people whose debts are co signed.

Automatic stay covers co signors

Unique to Chapter 13, Section 1301 of the Bankruptcy Code extends the protection of the automatic stay to those who are jointly liable with the debtor on consumer debts.

To qualify, the debt must be for a personal or household purpose.  

So a cosigned car loan is covered;

A cosigned business lease is not.

The benefits of the loan must have flowed to the person who filed bankruptcy.  If you co signed a loan made to a friend, your friend isn’t protected by your Chapter 13 stay.

Finally, to keep the stay in place, the Chapter 13 plan must provide for payment in full of the debt.

Co signed debts get preference

Chapter 13 plans are normally required to treat all unsecured, non priority debts the same.  Each of the general unsecured claims gets the same percentage payment through the plan.

But cosigned debts are excepted.  

The debtor can treat the cosigned debt differently and better than other debts.

It’s OK to separately classify a co signed debt and pay it in full, while other debts get little or nothing in Chapter 13.

So your plan can say:   pay 100% of the allowed claim on the joint credit card claim of BIG BANK, and far less to everyone else.

After the plan is over

The only sticky point for the co signor, who is protected from collection on the co signed debt during the plan, is that interest that may accrue on the debt over the life of the plan.

At the end of the plan, the principal on the debt and any interest owed when the case was filed, will have been paid.  But the bankruptcy case doesn’t stop the accrual of interest at the contract rate during the plan.

The cosignor will remain liable for that interest despite the bankruptcy.

Power of Chapter 13

The co debtor stay and the ability to separately classify co signed debts is just another reason why, as a bankruptcy attorney, I love Chapter 13.

Consider

The secrets of successful Chapter 13 plans

Interviewing a bankruptcy lawyer

Wipe out tax penalties in Chapter 13

What Should Bankruptcy Cost?

By

 

pay for bankruptcyPick the cheapest bankruptcy lawyer and it could really cost you.

How much time and skill does the cut-rate lawyer invest in your case?  Often, not enough to do the case right.

And the  extra cost of getting another lawyer to repair  a case gone bad is only half the problem. Not all the problems created by the bargain basement lawyer can be fixed.

Even when the case can be saved,  the clients will end up paying twice: one to the cheapo lawyer, and again to competent counsel to clean it up.

Undoubtedly, they’ll pay more than if  they’d paid a good lawyer to do it right the first time.

Bankruptcy mistakes

Right now, in my office we have three conversions from Chapter 11 to Chapter 7 involving significant real estate assets.

We have cases where big ticket assets were omitted.  We have cases where the initial attorney just didn’t persist with the debtor to get the schedules right, and ones where counsel didn’t explore the choice of chapter.

Almost without exception, the debtors chose counsel based on price.  They went with the lower price for their bankruptcy case, and they bought a rat’s nest.

Cost conscious only at the end

Why is it that notions of economy only surface after a client has wracked up tens of thousands of dollars in debt?

Many of the debtors gave more thought to credit card expenditures or purchases of investment real estate during the boom than they give to picking a bankruptcy lawyer.

The influx of lawyers to this field and the prevalence of lawyer advertising suggest bankruptcy law is a commodity.

Lawyers with no track record to tout or past clients to spread the word  compete on price.  If you can buy a $15 toaster, why pay $30? goes the thinking.

What a lawyer adds

The existence of non lawyer petition preparers and do-it-yourself books reinforce the idea that bankruptcy is more like playing Go Fish than contract bridge.

Bankruptcy no place for do-it-yourself

Then, there are the official forms, suggesting that filing bankruptcy is all about the paper and not about the disclosure the paper requires.

What the bankruptcy papers require

And disclosure is what the forms are all about, and the system wants disclosure because there may be consequences to the stuff disclosed.

Quality of counsel is not reliably correlated with price:  I’ve seen some utter newbie lawyers charging more than highly skilled veterans for an inferior product.  But capable counsel is seldom the cheapest.

So, my charge to those needing bankruptcy relief is to consider that hiring the least expensive lawyer is a poor bargain.

Figure how much should you pay for bankruptcy

Another time, I’ll talk about how to assess a lawyer’s suitability for your case.

Questions to ask a bankruptcy lawyer before you file

Image courtesy of purpleslog.

Two Strikes & You’re Out (Of Your Home)

By

bankruptcy stay

Three strikes and you’re out.  Anyone familiar with baseball knows that one.

The rules are different in bankruptcy.

Two strikes and you’re out.

And for one couple, they’re not only out of bankruptcy, they’re out of their house.

Foreclosed the day after they filed bankruptcy number three.

Because, what they didn’t know is that there is no automatic stay of foreclosure in a third bankruptcy filing.

Without a lawyer, they gambled and lost.

Bankruptcy reform is cruel

When Congress “reformed” bankruptcy law a decade ago, it limited the availability of the automatic stay in cases where the filer had had prior cases dismissed during the year.

Under the new law, the stay is automatic in a first case;  lasts for 30 days in a second case; and doesn’t exist at all in a third case.  See 11 U.S.C. 362(c)(3).

The rule looks at cases pending during the year and dismissed in the twelve months before the case at hand.

The change was intended to stop abuse of bankruptcy law by folks who filed bankruptcy only to get the stay of collection, folks who didn’t intend to follow through with a complete filing in accordance with the rules.

And certainly, there are a few examples of deliberate abuse of the law.

What you don’t know

The elderly couple in this story wanted to put off the foreclosure long enough to sell their home.  For reasons I haven’t figured out, with their house on the line, they opted to file a Chapter 13 without the help of a lawyer.

In each case, they filed a “skeleton” case, the bare bones necessary to initiate a bankruptcy case.

And in each case, they failed to file the balance of the schedules within the two week extension provided by the rules.

Under the “reformed” statute, the filing of their third case within the last 12 months didn’t trigger a stay against foreclosure.

So, when the lender foreclosed the day after they filed the third case, the lender was good under the law.

And the house was gone.

Do it yourself is dangerous

Usually, we admire the independent, the tenacious, the resourceful.  We applaud the d0-it-yourself ethic.

But law is not like carpentry or car maintenance.

Like it or not, law is complicated, rule-driven, and often inflexible.

Hiring a lawyer seems particularly painful when the problem you need to solve is not enough money.

But the pain of paying for help is minor next to losing your house, unnecessarily.

Bankruptcy lawyers are used to clients with few funds.  Chapter 13 provides a way to legally pay  your lawyer after you file your case.  We can often find a way to make it work.

In many ways, bankruptcy is a team sport: you and your lawyer. Victory is unlikely when you take the field short-handed.

More

How much should bankruptcy cost?

Timeline for foreclosure in California

How to interview a bankruptcy lawyer

At Risk of Repossession? How To Keep The Car & Pay Less

By

car repossessionIf you are one of the  7 million Americans late on your car payments and living in fear that your car will be repossessed, consider how Chapter 13 bankruptcy can save your wheels.

Losing your car can accelerate a torrent of nasty financial consequences.

No car, no way to work.

No work, no income.

So, what can a Chapter 13 bankruptcy do to put you back on the road?

Stop repossession

All chapters of bankruptcy impose an injunction on creditor efforts to collect debts, or enforce liens, automatically when you file.   That automatic stay applies whether or not the creditor knows about it.

So, file bankruptcy and any collection actions taken without court permission are void and legally ineffective.  If they pick up your car after you’ve filed, you can compel its return.

The only exception to the stay applying automatically is if you’ve had two bankruptcy cases dismissed in the past 12 months.  More on multiple dismissals.

Spread out car payments

Chapter 13 allows you to put forward a plan to restructure your car loan.  The remaining payoff balance on your car loan can be spread over 60 months.

Unless your car loan is very new, or the original term very long, that probably lowers what you pay each month through the plan.

Reduce interest rate

You can adjust the interest rate on a car loan paid through the plan to the current day, market rate.  As I write, that interest rate in California is between 4 and 5%.

This power to lower the interest rate is central to a successful readjustment of a high interest car loan.  It’s of little help if your loan is less that today’s market rate.

But Chapter 13 in the states of the 9th Circuit has another trick up its sleeve.

Strip out loan add ons

Part of a Chapter 13 plan can be cutting the car loan down to the portion of the loan that financed the car itself;  you can knock out any part of the loan that paid off an underwater trade-in, or a service contract, or gap insurance.

The 9th Circuit said in Penrod that these additions to the amount financed were not protected by the 2005 bankruptcy amendments that gave special consideration to car lenders.

So, you can pare down the car loan that has to be repaid to just the amount of the loan balance used to buy the car itself, and not all the extras.

Deal with other debts

You don’t just file bankruptcy on one debt; bankruptcy includes all your debts.

Some may be absolutely dischargeable, perhaps without paying anything on them.

Some liens can be wiped out.  Back payments on home loans can be caught up in Chapter 13.

Chances are that there’s more going on in your financial life than just the trouble with  your car loan.

An experienced bankruptcy lawyer can help you look at the big picture and propose a solution to keep you trucking.

More

Your car in Chapter 7 bankruptcy

Is bankruptcy the right choice for you

Interviewing a bankruptcy lawyer

 

 

 

Stupid Moves Before Seeing A Bankruptcy Lawyer

By

before bankruptcy

Don’t tidy up your financial affairs before consulting a bankruptcy lawyer.

Your current mess may present opportunities to plan your bankruptcy for a better outcome.

You may waste money or lose bankruptcy options when you make last minute changes to your situation without understanding how that situation plays out in bankruptcy.

You’ll have the widest set of options for a fresh start if your lawyer sees the situation as it is today.

What looks to you like complexity and disorder may look to your bankruptcy lawyer as opportunity and advantage.

The high cost of financial housecleaning

My heart sinks when a new client tells me that they’ve just paid off the loan their parents made them before seeing me.

Why your bankruptcy lawyer shouldn’t fight for you

Or borrowed against their retirement to fund debt management.

Or paid off the taxes so that all the remaining debt is credit cards.

For different reasons in each instance, those actions complicate a bankruptcy or squander assets that could have been saved in bankruptcy.

Payments to family

Paying off a loan from family seems instinctive.

We want to take care of those closest to us.  Sometimes, paying off help from family is driven by the desire to hide a bankruptcy from them.  Sometimes, it’s the desire to make sure they get whatever assets you have before you submit to the scrutiny of a bankruptcy trustee.

But more likely, paying off a debt to an insider (that’s bankruptcy lingo for close relatives, real or business related) hurts more than helps.  The bankruptcy trustee in a Chapter 7 can sue insiders who get paid during the 12 months before the bankruptcy filing to recover the money.

The theory of recovering preferences is to make a fair distribution of your assets to all creditors, not just the ones you favor.

Often, the exemptions that are available in bankruptcy will allow you to keep more money than you expect.  You can repay that debt to Mom after the filing, when it has no adverse consequences to Mom. The California grubstake (or wild card exemption) protects about $28,000 in any kind of property, in addition to other exemptions for specific kinds of property.

So, hold on to your checkbook, until we’ve talked.

Settlements before bankruptcy are wasted

The saddest thing I’ve seen recently was the family that soldiered through a five year debt settlement program before we met.  They had paid tens of thousands of dollars to creditors, but didn’t realize that not all their debts were included in the plan.

We had to file bankruptcy for them despite their heroic efforts to pay their debts.  They got no credit or advantage from the money they spent retiring credit cards while their property taxes and student loan debts fell into default.

The better situations are when clients ask if they should accept a settlement offer from a collector before filing.  There, at least, I get to ask what benefit they get from paying that money, money that could otherwise go to funding an IRA or paying down student loans?

In general, your bankruptcy is no simpler or cheaper or less damaging if you have a few creditors as opposed to many creditors.   If the situation requires bankruptcy, reducing the number of creditors or amount of the debt doesn’t benefit you at all.

Tax debt has its uses

While it isn’t generally thought to be a good thing to owe money to the tax collector, it may be an asset if your income is above the median for your state.

The means test is a formula that is supposed to weed out those families who make too much money to file Chapter 7. One of the ironies is that one of the allowed deductions in figuring whether you have too much income to file Chapter 7 is that you can deduct taxes you owe from the income.

It’s the same with mortgage arrearages and property taxes on your home.

These debts are useful deductions in getting a client into the bankruptcy chapter of their choice.

Pay it off before we meet and I have fewer tools to shape the means test.

Put down that broom

So, resist the temptation to clean up your finances before you meet with a bankruptcy lawyer.  Don’t sweep debts under the carpet or out the door before you understand the bigger picture.

Make any advantageous changes in consultation with your lawyer.

More

What your lawyer can’t tell you

The secret alternative to bankruptcy

Cheat sheet for interviewing a bankruptcy lawyer

 

Image courtesy of Flickr and Spengy. 

 

Credit Reports Heal

By

band-24298_1280 (1)_optWill filing bankruptcy hurt my credit? Probably.

Should that hit to your credit keep from filing bankruptcy?  Not by a long shot.

Incredibly, I encounter people drowning in debt who think their credit report is more important than their financial health.

Their thinking seems to be that credit, once damaged, is never the same.

It’s not so.

A blow to your credit is not permanent nor even long lasting.

Your “credit”, or really, your worthiness for new credit, is almost a living, breathing thing.  It can suffer a blow and recover.

Credit hit is like a cut

Whether you choose debt settlement, debt management or bankruptcy, the solution will damage your credit, in the short run.

Think of the damage like a wound.

The wound bleeds, it exposes the rest of your body to infection.  It hurts.

Think of bankruptcy as antiseptic.  Douse the wound with antiseptic to kill infection and promote healing and it hurts…but the hurt fades.

Over time, the wound closes and scabs over.  It isn’t painful most of the time.

When it’s healed, there’s a bit of a scar.

Over time, even the scar fades.

Debt is chronic disease

When your debts are beyond paying off in the normal course, it’s like a disease you can’t beat.  Persistent symptoms, sometimes progressively worse, other times just ever-present.

Debt saps your energy, consumes your thinking and limits your opportunities.

If your debts are such that you’ve considered bankruptcy, your credit worthiness is probably already compromised.  Would any creditor lend you more money at a reasonable rate?

If not, your credit may not be doing you any good at present.

Your balance sheet is what counts

A credit report is a limited history.  As time passes, the oldest history falls off the report to be replaced with the snapshot of today’s finances.

If you use bankruptcy to wipe away your old debts, your balance sheet (assets minus liabilities) improves on the spot.

The bankruptcy filing shows on your credit report, in the rear view mirror, for some time.  But its significance to lenders fades the farther down the road you get from filing.

But with your old debts gone, even right after you file, you no long look like someone who already has as much debt as they can handle  or more.

Take steps to get financially healthy and your credit will recover too.

More

Your right to credit reporting after bankruptcy

Tips for real estate loans after bankruptcy

Life after bankruptcy

Image courtesy of Flickr and RambergMedia Images under a Creative Commons license.

What Small Business Needs From Government

By

business challenges

 

This post was first published 10 years ago, in the midst of the Great Recession.  I continue to think about the real challenges of running a small business and the balance needed between simplicity for the business owner and protections for the public.  More below.

Senator McCain this morning on Meet the Press reprised the Republican view of the approach to stimulus:  tax cuts for small businesses.

I thought about the small businesses I had seen in the past couple of weeks.  Not one of them was paying income taxes, and their expenditure on payroll taxes was small, because they’d cut back on  employees.

For the very small business, I don’t see taxes as the culprit.

Everywhere you look you see the impact of credit cards on the economy.  Often it’s suit by American Express that brings a small business owner to my office.

Or the businessman makes a list of their credit card debt and the interest rates after the recent round of increases and realize that they can never pay off the debt at 28% interest.

Credit card merchant fees are a much bigger piece of the small business expense picture than are taxes for most of my clients.  Each merchant pays a percentage of each credit transaction to the card issuer.   7-Eleven store owners are petitioning  Congress for regulation of the fees charged merchants  by the card issuers .

I’m certainly not an economist and don’t have a Moran Plan for reinvigorating the economy, but the people I see in trouble aren’t there because of their tax burden.

Small business wish list

Ten years later, my wish list for entrepreneurs is greater simplicity on the administrative side of the business.

Perhaps fewer jurisdictions to deal with and regulations that the average Joe can understand and follow.  Less need for hired professionals to keep the business out of trouble.

Looking around in 2019, the regulatory changes we’re seeing don’t seem to be helping Mom and Pop businesses.

More

Pitfalls to avoid for small business

Your money needs a prenup

Myth of the business credit card

The Trouble With Your Social Security

By

Social Security call

The caller says your Social Security file is incomplete and without more information, your assets, as well as your benefits, will be frozen.

Pretty terrifying if you depend on Social Security checks.

Only, it’s not true.

The caller isn’t from Social Security.

Social Security can’t freeze your assets.

Social Security doesn’t do business by phone.

But scammers love the phone and they love trusting folks and vulnerable elders.

The caller is a thief

The guy, or the automated voice, on the phone really wants you to hand him your information so he can steal money.

It may be your money he wants to steal, if he gets your banking information.  Or, he wants to steal someone else’s money by pretending to be you.

Scammers also use the IRS cover because the IRS is feared;  just another way to get your attention.

The scammers use the Social Security cover story because Social Security impacts almost every American adult.  And, Social Security is trusted.

Through the magic of hacking, they even display the real Social Security phone number.  But it’s only real on your phone’s caller ID.

The other real thing is the threat to your financial wellbeing.

Only scammers make calls

The “fact” that your first contact about a supposedly dire situation comes by phone is a giveaway that the caller is a scammer.

Real government employees write letters.

They write, and write, and write.

They explain the problem.  They suggest what needs to happen next.  And none of their fixes involve providing critical identifying information over the phone.

They make a record that way that they’ve played by the rules.

When scammers call

Your strategy is simple:

clam up,then

hang up.

Tell them nothing.

But do tell the feds.  You can report the crooks online at   https://oig.ssa.gov/report .

If you continue to be worried about your Social Security account, call the real Social Security at 1-800-772-1213 or online at the SSA’s website.

Keep your personal information personal and private.

More

When the IRS is coming to arrest you

Debt collectors exploit elders via phone

Weapons of a debt collector

 

 

 

643 Bair Island Road
Suite 403
Redwood City, CA 94063
Phone: (650) 694-4700

Categories