• Home
  • Bankruptcy in Brief
  • ABC’s of Bankruptcy
  • Considering Bankruptcy
  • True Stories
  • Chapter 13
  • Blog
  • About Us

Northern California Bankruptcy Lawyer

On The Bankruptcy Soapbox

The Soap Box
  • How bankruptcy works
  • Mortgage Matters
  • Consumer Rights
  • Newsworthy
  • You & Your Lawyer
  • Small Business
  • Family Law

Personal Assets Can Be At Risk For Your Business Debts

By Cathy Moran

business debts

Business debt can bleed over into an entrepreneur’s personal assets.  Hearing me say that, my client was dumbfounded.

He was aghast that the generous equity in the home he and his wife owned was at risk when his corporate business folded.

That was not because the shareholder is liable for the corporation’s debts.  A properly operated corporation confines the business debts to the corporate entity.

How to properly sign for your corporation

No,  it’s because he signed the business lease in his individual name.  And because he was a corporate officer who didn’t pay all the corporation’s payroll taxes.

As a person liable for a debt, his assets (and the whole of the community property in California) are exposed to creditors.

While exemptions protect some assets, up to a specified dollar value,  the non exempt equity in the family home is at risk .

Understand the California homestead

When business vs. personal distinction matters

The only time that it matters whether an individual’s debt is personal rather than business is when figuring the infamous means test.  The means test applies only to those whose debts are “primarily consumer”.

So, debts incurred in business, taxes, and debts imposed by law are not “consumer” debts.

If those kinds of debts exceed the total of consumer debts, the means test doesn’t apply.  There is no need to “qualify” for bankruptcy relief by reason of income.

Sole proprietors are fully at risk

As a matter of debtor-creditor law, if your business is a proprietorship, there is no legal distinction between you and your business.  The debts you incur to run the business have the same legal rights to payment from your assets, personal and business,  as the debts incurred for personal living.

When the business is one with the business owner, failure to pay any debt imperils both business and business owner.

Isolating business debt

Corporations and LLC’s are legal “persons” invented to create a distinction between the business and the business owner.  The corporation can incur debt in its name alone, and only it is liable.

The practical catch is that vendors and landlords may not want to extend credit where the only “person” liable is a thinly capitalized corporation. They may insist on a guarantor.  Execute that guarantee of the corporation’s debt, and the individual has staked his personal assets to pay the debt.

The other way owners of corporate businesses become liable for the business debts is inattention.  They never change the vendor accounts to the corporate name when they incorporate.

They are sloppy about how they sign business agreements.

The myth of the corporate credit card

They take a business credit card and don’t realize that they are personally liable.

Who needs bankruptcy

In the case of the entrepreneur I met with, it turns out that the corporation is liable for very little and it can survive as an entity if there is a business future.

The shareholder, however, is a likely candidate for a Chapter 13, to keep the house and pay the debts over time.

More

Is it safe to file a corporate bankruptcy?

Asset protection for everyday folks

How exemptions work

Filed Under: Consumer Rights, Small business, True Stories Tagged With: 2017

Can Your Business Survive The Pandemic?

By Cathy Moran

ailing business
virus damaged business

Long after the human patients recover from the coronavirus, small businesses will still be struggling.

And long nights will be spent deciding whether to try to stay in business.

Here are some things to weigh as you consider the future of a struggling small business.

The desire to continue

The most important part of most small businesses is the owner. The owner supplies the vision and the drive that makes the business run.

If you are drained of vision and drive, then allow yourself to exit. Soldiering on just so you don’t have to admit you’re done is unlikely to have a good result.

If you’re game to continue, there are more questions.

Is the business viable

When the lock-down is over, and we creep back to the new “normal”, the next gating question is whether there’s a post pandemic market for the business’s product .

And if there is continuing demand for the product, how long is the ramp up?  What financial resources does it take to survive the ramp up? And what’s the likely volume of business to be expected over the short run? The longer run?

Reorganize for survival

The pandemic has forced change and re evaluation on all of us.  When things are already disrupted, considering change seems less overwhelming. And more essential.

Could the business continue with

  • fewer owners
  • fewer employees
  • no brick and mortar premises
  • narrower market
  • broader market
  • partnered with others

Embrace the disruption and move the pieces around the board, at least in your mind.

New debt and lingering death

Business loans seem to be at the center of the government’s recovery strategy. Distressingly, the rules about when/if those loans need to be repaid are unclear, incomplete, and subject to change.

It’s worth some thought as to whether the business can handle more debt. What is the current debt structure, and were you paying that debt down before the pandemic?

Another way to think about more borrowing is that it may be essential as a short term strategy to keep food on the table until you have more options outside of the current business.

Wind down and move on

Writing the existing  business off as a lost cause isn’t necessarily an all or nothing choice.

Perhaps you fold the existing business but remain in the same industry, as a proprietor rather than an entity, or as an entity after a personal bankruptcy.

Dangers inherent in corporate Chapter 7

Maybe, this is the time to change industries, take a salaried job, return to school, or ????

Challenges for all

The issues are complex and intertwined. And with the virus still shadowing our lives, uncertainty abounds. Allow yourself some time to consider how you move forward.

More

Collected posts on coronavirus impact on personal finances

Separating yourself from your business

New laws reacting to COVID

Filed Under: Consumer Rights, Small business

The Risks Of Filing Bankruptcy For Your Corporation

By Cathy Moran

risk of business bankruptcy
risk of business bankruptcy

When your incorporated business fails,  the instinctive reaction is to file bankruptcy for the corporation.

But a corporate bankruptcy comes with risk to the shareholders.

I know you incorporated to separate yourself as the owner from the risks of the business.  As a separate legal “person”, the corporation is distinct from the individuals who own the stock in the corporation.

But when the business has to shut down, the actual degree of separation is tested.

You need to know, up front,  if the business can safely file bankruptcy.

Or, will using bankruptcy to shut down the business drag the owners down as well?

Can this corporation safely file bankruptcy?

Businesses looking for bankruptcy relief typically file Chapter 7.  The business closes, a trustee is appointed, and any valuable assets are sold for the benefit of creditors.

The trustee then controls the corporate checkbook and the timeline on which creditors get paid through the courts.

Bankruptcy trustees are further empowered to recover money paid by the debtor corporation where the transfer is a preference or a fraudulent transfer.  That’s the beginning of the complications in a business Chapter 7.

Before choose bankruptcy as the method for winding down, consider these five potential complications.

1.   Owe payroll taxes?

Corporate officers may have personal liability to the IRS and any state taxing authority for amounts withheld from the paychecks of employees.  Liability may extend to anyone with signature authority on the corporate bank account

This liability exists whether the corporation files bankruptcy or winds down outside of bankruptcy.

More about “borrowing” from Uncle Sam

Filing corporate bankruptcy may preserve assets from other aggressive creditors from which those taxes can be paid.  That benefits the individual officers, since every dollar the trustee pays on payroll taxes reduces what they’ll have to pay.

But bankruptcy empowers the trustee to hire professionals, investigate the debtor’s books, and pursue recovery of money owed to the corporation, either under state law, or under bankruptcy law.

The expenses of that pursuit are paid ahead of the priority taxes.

Thus a bankruptcy filing could work to shrink the pool of money for payment of payroll taxes, and drag out the time before payment is made.

2.  Made guarantees?

Landlords often require the personal guarantee of the individual shareholders before they commit to a real property lease for the corporation.  Or the lease may have been in the shareholder’s name from the start.

Sign correctly for your corporation so you’re not liable

Any individual guarantor on a lease gets no protection from his obligations to the landlord when the tenant corporation files bankruptcy.

When a corporation files Chapter 7, a trustee is appointed. He calls the shots and he’s got the keys to the leased premises.  All the while, the rent clock is ticking, increasing the guarantor’s exposure.

Trustees are usually quick to either vacate the premises or surrender it back to the landlord, freeing the landlord to look for new tenants.

But  pre bankruptcy lease arrears have no priority for payment in the bankruptcy case.  If there is a dividend payable to the landlord, it may be small and far in the future.  The individual is on the hook in the mean time.

3.  Used corporate credit cards ?

Almost without exception, some living, breathing human being is personally liable for every credit card.  Even if the card has the business name embossed on it, the application for that card undoubtedly contains a promise of the owner to pay the card issuer.

So, any liability of the individuals on the credit card won’t be eliminated by the business’s bankruptcy.

The myth of the corporate credit card

It can get worse:  the corporation may not, in fact, be liable at all on the card.  Not all “business credit cards” are really issued to the business. They’re issued to the people who run the business.

Filing bankruptcy doesn’t make the situation worse:  if the corporation is liable and if there are assets to pay creditor claims, the credit card folks get something toward the balance.  Only it’s a long time down the road.

Just don’t expect the corporation’s bankruptcy to absolve you for business credit cards.

4.  Benefited from paying the bills?

File bankruptcy for the business, and you may get yourself sued by the trustee for an avoidable preference.

When you and the business are jointly liable for a debt, every payment the business makes on that debt reduces your personal exposure to the creditor.  And that, in the eyes of the law, is a preference.

Payments the business made on the joint debt benefit you.  If other bills weren’t getting paid, we have an unfair discrimination between creditors of the business.  The trustee is authorized to sue you to make it more fair to other creditors.

The problem of preferences is the only item on this list of complications that is unique to bankruptcy.  Depending on the facts of the business’s operation, filing a Chapter 7 may just invite a lawsuit against you as the shareholder.

5.  Enjoyed  business help with personal expenses?

The more corporate money that flowed to insiders, the greater the threat that a bankruptcy trustee will challenge the payments,.

“Challenge” here is shorthand for “sue you”, or at least look hard at expenditures that made life easier for shareholders at a time when other creditors weren’t getting paid.

Often, the facts are just the opposite:  the shareholders were putting more money into the corporation, or going without to keep the business afloat.

But the idea of a fraudulent transfer, a payment for which the payor did not get a fair return for its money, has a long lookback period.  A bankruptcy trustee could be looking back years to see if the shareholders got more than was fair under fraudulent transfer law.

And if the books and records are sketchy, the shareholders may end up spending lots of time producing documents or explaining what happened.

Even if the end result is OK, the experience can be unnerving.

The bankruptcy takeaway

How to close-out a failed corporate business can be complex.  While I’ve listed the ways a corporate bankruptcy might end up biting the shareholders, the benefits can be equally significant.

File bankruptcy and much of the wind down work passes to the trustee.  The business creditors understand there is nothing available to pay their claims against the corporation.  Assets are distributed in an orderly and predictable manner.

Before you file bankruptcy for a corporation, make sure you’ve asked yourself the five questions I’ve laid out.  Take your answers to experienced bankruptcy counsel for a review.

More

Winding up a failed business

Struggling businesses in a time of pandemic

Filed Under: Featured, Small business

Incorporating A Troubled Business: Work-around Or Worse?

By Cathy Moran

business bankruptcy
multi faceted issue

Facets on a gem bend light and change how we see things.

The same thing happens when bankruptcy law encounters a small business owner and the business itself.

Seen from one angle of the law, the business is a valuable asset.

Seen from another, it is nothing more than a job for the owner, having no real value without the owner.

It depends on where you stand and where the light hits.

What’s the danger in incorporating?

The question comes up when individuals do business as a proprietorship. The business may provide a living to the proprietor who works there day to day, but the accumulating debt is debt of the individual.

I wrote earlier about how incorporation could create a separate legal entity that could continue to operate during the bankruptcy of its shareholders.

My good friend attorney Doug Jacobs pointed out that under some circumstances, incorporation could be seen as a fraudulent transfer.  And that’s not good.

A fraudulent transfer is one where the entity conveying property either intends to put it beyond the reach of his creditors, or, receives less than the asset was worth in exchange, leaving the transferor less able to pay his debts.

The bankruptcy code allows the bankruptcy trustee to recapture assets transferred in fraud of creditors.

My counter argument to Doug’s point is that incorporation hardly conveys away the value of the business, as the debtor simply exchanges his outright ownership of the business for outright ownership of the stock in the corporation that owns the business.

If there is real value there, a bankruptcy trustee can reach it by dissolving the corporation.

My second argument is that before incorporation, the business was indistinguishable from the individual. The idea of “transferring” debts to the newly created corporation is facially pleasing, but incorporation cannot relieve the individual of any liability he had before incorporation.

It is an axiom of law that no agreement between two entities can bind a third: that is, the individual and his corporation cannot by agreement cut off the right of the individual’s creditor to look to the individual for repayment, even though the new corporation and the individual might agree that the corporation will be henceforth liable.

This analysis is probably more theoretical than real.

The small businesses my clients usually operate are little more than personal services businesses. Incorporation simply provides cover for the trustee who, because of incorporation, doesn’t have to shut the business down as part of his duties to preserve the assets of the estate.

Law colored by local culture

But whether you see incorporation representing a meaningful transfer or not, the issue highlights the fact that the legal culture does vary from place to place.

I practice in Silicon Valley; Doug practices in the Central Valley. Like it or not, even though the law is the same in both places, judges often bring a slightly different perspective to the bench, depending on where they practice.

For that reason, when you select a bankruptcy lawyer, you want one who knows the judges before whom your case will be heard and understands the legal culture in that community.

Image:  Nemo & Pixabay

Filed Under: Consumer Rights, Small business

Bail Yourself Out Of Payroll Tax Trouble

By Cathy Moran

parachute-851318_640 (1)

Business owners with unpaid payroll taxes are in deep trouble.

Even if the employer is a corporation, the corporation’s managers are personally liable for the trust fund portion of unpaid payroll taxes. There’s no corporate shield when it comes to payroll taxes.

The trust fund portion of the tax (the amount withheld from employees’ checks) can be assessed against anyone  who could have paid that money  to the IRS.

You are in the IRS’s cross hairs, personally, if the business hands out “net” checks to employees without sending the withheld money in.  A bankruptcy discharge is no help here.

What’s the payroll tax

What we refer to as “payroll tax” is really a combination of two elements:  the employee’s income and FICA taxes that the employer has withheld and the employer’s share of FICA  (Social Security) tax.

The portion of the “payroll tax” withheld from the employee’s check are the “trust fund” portion of the payroll tax. Usually, trust funds make up about 2/3rds of the payroll tax.  The balance is the business’s matching contribution to Social Security.

The liability of corporate officers or LLC managers for the business’s trust fund liability is not dischargeable in bankruptcy.  Like other federal taxes, the statute of limitations is 10 years and the IRS is a fearsome creditor.

Earmark tax payments

If you find yourself in this pickle, you, and the business itself, can bail yourself out of trouble with an earmark of any payment you make toward Form 941 liability.

A taxpayer  who makes voluntary payments to the IRS has the right to designate to which liability the payment will be applied.  In re Ribs-R-Us, Inc., 828 F.2d 199, 201 (3rd Cir. 1987).

Cooper-AZ-brand-cropped

An earmark allows the IRS to distinguish your payment from others, like a cropped ear lets a cattleman tell his cows from his neighbors.

It is simply a direction to the IRS as to how the payment is to be credited.  Pay voluntarily and you have the right to tell the IRS what to do with the money.

Without instructions, the IRS is free to apply payment it receives on the tax debt as it chooses.  And it chooses the manner of application that benefits it best.

Send a check for payroll taxes and if the check is not enough to pay the entire liability, the IRS applies it first to the dischargeable portion of the tax first, preserving the personal liability of the business owners for the remaining tax.

Likewise, if the IRS levies an account, they may apply the levied funds as they wish.

How to earmark

If the business finds itself with insufficient funds to pay the entire tax owed, you can reduce your personal liability for the unpaid tax by earmarking the payment.

Write directions on the check specifying how the payment is to be applied like this:  Trust Fund liability, 4th Quarter 2015 941.  Send a cover letter with the check with the same instructions.  Keep a copy of the letter for your records.

Of course, the better course of action is to remain current on payroll taxes.

Use a payroll service that won’t cut the checks unless the taxes are paid, or make a tax  deposit  with each payroll.

Dip into the money withheld from employees and you’ve taken a “loan” that lives very nearly forever.

More

The easiest business loan in town-not

Is it safe to file a corporate bankruptcy

Reorganize or wind down?

Filed Under: Consumer Rights, Small business, Taxes Tagged With: 2016

The Easiest Business Loan In Town

By Cathy Moran

Easy loans have consequences
Easy loans have consequences

Running a small business is hard work.  

Cash flow is tight; time is in short supply.

When there’s just not enough in the bank to cover payroll, the easiest loan in town is from the Bank of Uncle Sam.

There’s no application, no review, no waiting.

You just give employees their checks, net of the amounts withheld.  You can repay the withheld amounts when cash flow is better, you tell yourself.

Up until now, that maneuver was costly and the financial consequences unavoidable.  Now, in California, it’s also criminal.

California employers exposed

Senate Bill 390, signed into law in October, 2013, makes it a crime for an employer to fail to pay over to taxing authorities money withheld from employees’ paychecks.

As little as $500 unpaid, and the matter is a felony.  The easy “loan” can result in hard time.

Responsibility for payroll taxes

Incorporating a business appears insulate the owners and managers of a business from liability for the debts of the business.

Payroll taxes, or more precisely, trust fund taxes, are an exception.

Trust fund taxes is the label given to the amounts that are withheld from an employees wages.  The withholding includes the employee’s contribution to FICA or Social Security, as well as the employee’s income tax withholding.

The employer holds those funds in trust.  The funds belong to the employee and are entrusted to the employer to transmit to the appropriate state and federal tax authorities.

Failure to remit withheld taxes

Both federal and California law hold corporate management personally responsible if the corporate employer doesn’t pay over the withheld funds.

The tax folks see it as almost theft or embezzlement when the employer diverts that money to the corporation’s purposes.  Even if  management sees the  failure to pay as a matter of survival, there’s little understanding available if you short the taxes.

If the money is withheld from the employee’s paycheck, the tax authorities will give the employee credit for the withheld money.  They see the employee as having done everything expected of him.

The tax authorities then pursue with a vengance every person in corporate management who could have signed the check to remit the funds as expected.

So the liability for the quickie loan spreads over all individuals with decision making power in the business.

Trust fund liability not dischargeable in bankruptcy

Civil liability for unpaid trust fund taxes cannot be wiped out in a bankruptcy filing.

The responsible-person penalty for failing to pay trust fund amounts is collectible for 10 years from assessment.

So, even before it became criminal, handing out net checks and pocketing the difference had consequences.

Now, the consequences include conviction for a crime.

Warning signal

If you are faced with an approaching payroll, and no way to pay all of the taxes and withholding associated with payroll, it’s time to have a serious discussion about the future of the business.

It’s one thing to fail in business;  it’s quite another to become a felon.

Image courtesy of Flickr and Infomatique.

Filed Under: Small business, Strictly California

Who Owns Your Business When You File Bankruptcy?

By Cathy Moran

business bankruptcy

business bankruptcy

The bankruptcy trustee’s question was straightforward (if inartful) yet the business owner nearly blew the answer.

The trustee asked:  are you the sole owner of your business?

When my client hesitated, she followed up:  are you a sole proprietor?

Focusing on the fact that he was the only person with an interest in the business, he said yes.

Wait a minute, was my response. That’s not so.

It took several minutes of sworn testimony at the first meeting of creditors to sort the matter out.

Who owns the corporate business

We were once again experiencing the phenomenon of the shape-shifting business owner.  The businessman had, in his mind, morphed into a sole proprietor rather than a stockholder.

The debtor was the sole owner of the corporation that owned and operated the failed business.

He was correct that no one else had an interest.  He skipped over the part that it was another legal entity, his corporation, that actually owned the assets and owed the debts of the business.

He owned the corporation that owned the business.

Why it matters

A sole proprietor owns a business as a personal asset.  In law, he owns the assets of the business and is liable for its debts.

A sole proprietorship has no legal existence separate from the owner.  The proprietorship may adopt a fictitious business name, but behind that dba is the individual who owns and operates the business.

So, if my client were a sole proprietor, the inventory of the business would have been an asset of the bankruptcy estate created when he filed bankruptcy.  The business bank accounts would fall to the control of the trustee.

When a corporation is created, it becomes a legal entity distinct from the individuals who own the shares in the corporation.  The corporation can have its own debts and its own funds that don’t belong directly to the shareholders.

That’s why business people incorporate:  to create a legal “person” that can take risks without exposing the shareholder’s other assets to that risk.

When my client filed his Chapter 7 case, his stock in the corporation was an asset of the bankruptcy estate, but not the business itself.  The business was owned and operated by the corporation.

Since the corporation had tons of debts, the stock that the bankruptcy trustee could administer had no net value.  That’s because, equity holders get money when a corporation liquidates only after creditors of the corporation have been paid off.

The takeaway

The first meeting of creditors in a bankruptcy case is the trustee’s opportunity to gather more information about what the debtor owns and owes.

Once you focus on what the trustee needs to get from the meeting, it’s easier to answer correctly and avoid the confusion that happened in my case.

When confusion ensues, it’s important to sort it out on the spot.

And that’s how I earned my keep in this case.

More

Rules for testifying at a bankruptcy hearing

How corporate officers can avoid personal liability

When a business needs to wind down

Filed Under: Consumer Rights, Small business, True Stories Tagged With: 2018

Myth Of The Corporate Credit Card

By Cathy Moran

business credit card

business credit cardAs far as myths go, the myth of the business credit card ranks right up there with  unicorns, Big Foot, and leprechauns .

Every struggling small business owner who crosses the threshold of my office believes that his corporate credit card is not a personal debt.

Wrong.

In 39 years of bankruptcy practice, I have never seen a credit card for which a living, breathing human being was not liable.  Not one.

The card may have the corporate business name on it.  Mine says  Cathleen Moran, Moran Law Group.  

But in fact, my corporation is not even jointly liable with me on that card.  It’s just me on the hook.

Which is scary given that these “business” cards are marketed as another form of business financing.  Their debt limits are easily five figures and many businesses have a drawer full of them.

The 23% business loan

What is insidious about business credit cards is their impact on the likelihood of a small business using them becoming profitable.

Just like the consumer credit card, business folks are conditioned to think they’re doing OK in business if they make regular payments on the 23% loan they have from Big Bank on the card.

But it takes a hell of a business to pay 23% for seed capital and make a profit.

Yet few business plans look at the cost of funds when assessing how they’re doing.

Business cards when business craters

There’s a perverse “benefit” to the fact the business isn’t liable for the credit card if the corporate business gets in financial trouble.  The card isn’t a debt of the corporation.

More times than I can count, the corporate business can continue on, assuming that there is a path forward, and the shareholder can file bankruptcy and ditch the credit card balance.

The corporation is a separate legal person and the bankruptcy of its shareholder doesn’t directly impact the corporation.  And it’s far easier and cheaper to reorganize the financial affairs of the shareholder in Chapter 13 than it is to reorganize a corporation in Chapter 11, the only form of bankruptcy that gets a corporation a discharge.

Now, the business has to have a plan for funding operations without the shareholder’s credit cards.  But, if we face the fact that the business doesn’t have to service that debt either going forward, the numbers may look different.

Seems there are two sides to every coin, and every card.

More

“B” is for business in my Bankruptcy Alphabet

How to sign the corporation’s name

Your business needs a prenup

Draft an enforceable contract without a lawyer

Filed Under: Consumer Rights, Small business Tagged With: 2017

SBA Loans Collectible Long Past Business Failure

By Cathy Moran

SBA collection

 

The SBA has eagle eyes and sharp talons when it comes to collecting from guarantors of business loans.

SBA collection tools are ruthless, efficient and ageless.

So I learned when a client consulted me about a business that had failed 12 years ago.

Yet the SBA had never sued him, nor had it filed a lien on his home.

He reported that every time he changed jobs, however, the SBA just appeared and garnished his wages.

At this rate, his exposure on his SBA loan guarantee will live long beyond the next decade.

Statute of limitations

The United States Code 28 USC 2415 prescribes a six year statute of limitations on lawsuits to collect non tax debts owed to the US.

That six year period is reset with each payment the feds receive on the debt.

Understand the liability of a guarantor

So, the SBA has six years from the last payment made to file a lawsuit against a guarantor for a money judgment.  With a judgment comes a slew of collection tools under the law, including liens  and levies.

But, it turns out, the feds don’t need a judgment to exercise powerful collection actions that usually require a judgment.

Administrative garnishment

Like the IRS, the SBA has a right to garnish wages without ever going to court.

13 C.F.R. 140.11  lays out both the limits on how much of each paycheck can be garnished and the procedure for challenging a garnishment.

Chillingly, the regulation provides that the feds have the right to garnish until the debt is satisfied, or until there is a settlement.  So that’s how the SBA kept surfacing for my client at each new job.

Offset into retirement years

Retirement isn’t a reprieve from SBA debt, either.

The government retains the right to offset any money it may owe you, as in tax refunds or Social Security benefits, to pay the debt. 31 USC 3716.

So, the passage of time will bar the initiation of a law suit that could result in a lien or a right to levy your assets, but the right to garnish wages or offset
mutual debts appears to have no time limit.  A guarantor of the debt of a long dead business may be paying on that debt until the guarantor’s death.

SBA debts dischargeable in bankruptcy

If an SBA borrower isn’t able to reach a settlement of the debt with the SBA, any unsecured debt to the SBA  is fully dischargeable in bankruptcy.

Secured debt owed to the SBA is only secured in a bankruptcy case to the extent that there is equity in the asset after liens senior to the SBA are paid. Thus in a Chapter 13, an SBA lien can be crammed down to the value of the collateral.

In the usual circumstances, the SBA is not protected by the provisions of Chapter 13 that bar modification or bifurcation of debts secured only by the debtor’s home:  SBA debts are almost always secured by the assets of the business for whom the loan was taken out.

More

No tax consequences when SBA guarantees compromised

Is a corporate bankruptcy safe for shareholders?

Thoughts on winding down failing business

Filed Under: Consumer Rights, Small business Tagged With: 2020

Closing Up Shop

By Cathy Moran

closing business

What can you do when it becomes obvious that your  business should close?

The hardest part of being in business is recognizing when the business has no future and needs to close.  Yet the overwhelming majority of new businesses fail within 5 years.

So you’re not alone.  In fact, in the face of the pandemic, you’re in great company.

Shutting down an insolvent business presents a tough challenge: honoring the legal rights of creditors while minimizing the damage to the founders and employees.

Not to mention the emotional hit.

Separating the owner from the business

Unless you are a sole proprietor, you and your business are two separate legal entities.

Whether your business operates as a corporation or an LLC, it has its own rights and obligations.  Those rights and obligations  may be different from yours as the shareholder.

For the purposes of this discussion, we’re going to assume the business is a corporation. If you operated as an LLC, the issues are essentially the same as those of a corporation.

  • The board of directors of an insolvent corporation owes its duty of loyalty to the creditors, not the owners.
  • Creditor claims get paid before the shareholder’s ownership claims.
  • Shareholders can be creditors as well as owners.
  • Management can legally pay some creditors and not others.

Keep these precepts in mind once you see the business needs to close.

Bankruptcy or not

There is no clear or universal answer to whether a failed business should file a Chapter 7.

A corporation does not get a discharge in a Chapter 7 case; only a Chapter 11 reorganization erases the debts of a corporation.  And a Chapter 11 is worth the significant time and expense only if the business has a future, or some valuable asset salable only if the business continues until the sale.

So the only purpose a business bankruptcy serves is to liquidate the business assets and satisfy creditors as far as possible.  The unpaid debts will remain enforceable against the corporation for as long as the law allows.

Companies can go out of business without filing bankruptcy: they liquidate their assets and cease operations. Creditors have a right to recover their claims from the assets of the corporation.

If there are no assets, the corporation cannot be further harmed by lawsuits that try to collect from the corporation: a judgment against a company without assets is worthless.

Closing without bankruptcy

It’s perfectly legal and rational to simply close the doors and cease business without involving the courts.

The danger to management in this approach is the tendency of some creditors to assume that the business’s failure to pay means that there is some sort of skullduggery afoot.  Those creditors don’t recognize the legal distinction between the corporation that runs the business and the people who work for and own the corporation.

It becomes easy and reflexive for such creditors to sue the officers as well as the corporation to collect the debt.  The corporation may have no remaining assets but the officers have both assets and future earnings at stake.

While the claim against the individuals may be invalid, the individual has to appear and defend in the lawsuit, or a judgment will be entered against him.

And sometimes, the individuals are liable because the individual guaranteed the debt or even the individual opened the account before the corporation was formed.

Why doing it yourself can work

Personally managing the wind up has advantages, if you are willing to devote the time and energy to the process.

Management can usually get a better price for assets since they know the market, know the asset, and are motivated to get highest recovery.

Outside of bankruptcy, you control who gets paid with the available funds.
You can act swiftly to limit exposure of management or investors by paying first debts guaranteed by insiders, subletting leased space, returning leased equipment, etc.

Creditors are protected from having to give back preferential payments to the bankruptcy trustee.

Assets can be sold to insiders so long as the price is fair.

All desireable outcomes, if it’s possible.

DIY isn’t all roses

But…
Handling the shut down yourself has some down side. DIY may

  • Prevent management from accepting new employment
  • Require cooperation from creditors and lessors
  • Increase likelihood that disgruntled creditor will sue individuals too

Bankruptcy is simple

In Chapter 7, the bankruptcy trustee becomes responsible for liquidating assets, returning equipment, and dealing with creditors, freeing management to turn to other endeavors

The trustee has powers under Bankruptcy Code to sell leases despite anti assignment provisions and to avoid levies and writs of attachment, recovering value for creditors that isn’t possible outside of bankruptcy.

Filing bankruptcy seems to reduce the instance of creditors suing individual managers for corporate debt.

The automatic stay prevents aggressive creditors from diverting cash that could be used to pay taxes, employees, and guaranteed debts or recovering property needed for wind up.

But….
If the bankruptcy trustee winds up the business:

  • Trustee unlikely to get top dollar for saleable assets.
  • Insiders may be prohibited from buying technology, intellectual property or projects in development
  • Trustee’s fees and expenses are paid off the top
  • Trustee can recover preferences to trade creditors and to insiders and challenge pre petition transfers of assets if legally fraudulent
  • Bankruptcy process frequently slow and inexact
  • Claims are paid according to priorities in the Bankruptcy Code

Try some of each

The choice of how to wind up doesn’t have to be an either/or decision.

Management can liquidate assets as far as feasible, and file bankruptcy thereafter to let the trustee mop up.

Step back and look at the issues of timing, asset value, and creditor claims.

If the answers seem complex, consult a bankruptcy lawyer for help weighing the alternatives.

More

Payroll tax trouble

Separating the business from the business owner

Myth of the corporate business card

Filed Under: Consumer Rights, Small business Tagged With: 2017

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • Next Page »
Coronavirus & Your Finances

About The Soapbox

You've arrived at the Bankruptcy Soapbox, a resource of bankruptcy information and consumer law.

Soapbox is a companion site to Bankruptcy in Brief, where I try to be largely explanatory and even handed (Note I said "try").

Here, I allow myself to tell stories and express strong opinions on how I think law should work for the consumer and small businesses when it comes to debt.

Moran Law Group
Bankruptcy specialists for individuals and small businesses in the San Francisco Bay Area

How Bankruptcy Works

When Can I File Bankruptcy Again

You can file bankruptcy tomorrow, so long as you don't currently have a bankruptcy case pending. When you can get a discharge in that case is a different story. The Bankruptcy Code limits the frequency of getting a discharge, not the filing and completion of the bankruptcy case. My friend Gene Melchionne wrote … Read more

More Posts from this Category

643 Bair Island Road
Suite 403
Redwood City, CA 94063
Phone: (650) 694-4700

Categories

All content copyright © Moran Law Group. All rights reserved.