Northern California Bankruptcy Lawyer

On The Bankruptcy Soapbox

The Soap Box

What You Think About Chapter 13 Is Dead Wrong

By

bankruptcy misunderstanding

The difference between bankruptcy’s Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 is often expressed this way:   

Liquidation: the process of turning assets into cash

Chapter 7 is a liquidation proceeding

Chapter 13 is a repayment plan

 

And therein lies the biggest misconception about Chapter 13: 

13 does not repay everything you owe.

It’s a repayment plan alright, but not necessarily a 100% repayment .

You may not pay much at all, to any creditor.  It depends.

How much you repay

The amount you repay to creditors through your plan is determined by comparing

Rough and dirty, you calculate the number for each of these factors, and your plan must pay the largest of the three tests.  That payment is spread over 3 to 5 years.

Which creditor gets 100%

Bankruptcy law gives special standing for repayment to two common kinds of creditors.

  • Family support (alimony, child support, or other Domestic Support Obligations)
  • Recent income taxes or payroll taxes

These creditors have a priority for payment,  ahead of all other unsecured creditors.  They get paid in full.  The interest that accrues on family support obligations even survives the Chapter 13 discharge.

Therefore, to get court approval of a plan, the plan payments must be sufficient to make these payments, along with any fees of the Chapter 13 trustee and any of your attorneys fees to be paid through the plan.

Unsecured creditors out of luck

The brutal truth is that general unsecured creditors holding medical bills, personal loans, judgments for money, and credit card debt may get nothing in Chapter 13.

That’s because the available money is paid first to priority claims and the costs of administration of the case.  So a debtor with little disposable income may propose a plan that pays only the costs of the plan and the priority creditors.

Chapter 13 makes creditors face reality

The strength of Chapter 13 is that it often forces unsecured creditors to accept that there simply isn’t enough money to pay their claim.

The bankruptcy schedules show it, and the bankruptcy judge enforces it.

It is that coercive effect that makes Chapter 13 so much more effective than debt settlement:  if the numbers support it, the plan can pay them little or nothing.

So, don’t be put off by the phrase “repayment plan”.

Chapter 13 pays creditors only what you can afford, over a limited period of time, in the order of the importance of the debt.

That’s why I love Chapter 13.

More

Debt settlement is a dud

How secured debt can scuttle a Chapter 13

What bankruptcy should cost

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

7 Keys To Keeping Your House: Chapter 13 After You File

By

keep the house

Filing Chapter 13 bankruptcy stops the foreclosure.  You’ve protected your home, for the moment.

Bankruptcy gets you a sheltered legal environment to address the problems with your mortgage.

You heave a sigh of relief.

But the fight to keep your house isn’t over, just because there’s a stay.  You’ve just gotten through the first round.

You need to stay on your toes for the balance of the match to emerge with your house safe at the end of your bankruptcy.

Here’s what you need to know.

Mortgage lenders get special consideration

In the bankruptcy context,  the mortgage lender gets privileged treatment.

Anglo Saxon law, from which US law is drawn, has long given particular protection to the claims of property owners.  After all, it was those who owned property who wrote the laws.

The mortgage lender gets that special treatment because the lender’s lien is a property interest in your home.

That lien entitles the lender to regular payments;  if payments aren’t made, the lender can ask for relief from stay to foreclose.

The exception is if the value of the collateral is less than the total of the liens ahead of the lien in question.  Think:  underwater second mortgage.

Follow these 7 keys for keeping your house AND getting a discharge in Chapter 13.

1.  Regular mortgage payments required

Most Chapter 13 plans provide that the trustee pays the arrears on your mortgage, while you make the payments that come due after filing.

Make the payments- that means property taxes and insurance as well.

Too often, homeowners get fixated on paying the arrearages on their mortgage that they overlook, or struggle, with the ongoing payments.

Court are intolerant of borrowers who want the protection of the bankruptcy stay, but don’t take seriously their obligation to pay the monthly payments that come due after filing.

That intolerance spills over into dismissal of  Chapter 13 cases without a discharge when debtors fail to make current payments.

2.  Look for other liens

Chapter 13 isn’t limited to fixing problems with mortgage liens.  Your plan can either avoid altogether or reduce the amount of tax or judgment liens,

Make sure that you check the public record to see if any avoidable liens have attached, unnoticed, to your home.

If you find liens, your plan can cut them down to size.

3.  Pursue modification

Your best bet may be to agree with the lender on a modification of your mortgage.  Nothing in Chapter 13 stops the parties from considering modification.

Northern California bankruptcy judges have decreed that negotiations for a modification do not violate the automatic stay

Frequently, the modified mortgage either folds the arrears into the loan balance, to be paid over the life of the loan. Or, modification designates a portion of the amount owed as not bearing interest, but payable at loan-end or sale.

A modification that cures the arrears may eliminate the mortgage arrears portion of a Chapter 13 monthly payment, thereby increasing the chances of success.

4.  Review the lender’s claim

In order to be paid in a Chapter 13, a creditor must file a proof of claim.  For mortgages secured by the debtor’s principal residence, a detailed attachment is required.

The mortgage attachment must account for payments and charges to the loan from the date of the first, uncured default.

The POC also contains an analysis of any escrowed taxes and insurance, and the adequacy of the monthly payment to pay those expenses.

Dig into these numbers and see if they match your payment records and whether they are otherwise complete.

There’s lots of data there, some of it correct and some woefully wrong.

5.  Keep records of  your payments

Too many mortgage servicers fail the fundamental task of accepting your payments and crediting them properly.

The method of accounting changes with bankruptcy:  payments made after filing are supposed to be credited to a separate accounting for your loan, while the pre bankruptcy record stands alone

Servicers don’t always do that.  Payments sometimes sit for months on someone’s desk, undeposited.

I tell clients to pay with paper checks on their accounts and send the payment by a method that gets you a receipt upon delivery to the servicer.

It’s a hassle, I know, but you end up with a record from your bank that the check was cashed, and you have proof that it was delivered.  The added expense is nothing to the cost of your attorney having to track down the facts showing you paid.

6.  Read payment change notices

If your monthly mortgage payment changes after you file bankruptcy, the servicer must send you a Notice Of Payment Change.

The change may be driven by an interest rate change or a change in the cost of escrowed taxes or insurance.

Even though it comes on a court form, and looks dense, you’ve got to read it and adjust your post filing payments on your mortgage accordingly.

If you’re uncertain, ask your lawyer.

7.  Exploit case-end rules

When you’ve made your last payment to the trustee, bankruptcy rules require a notice to the mortgage servicer about the state of your loan balance.

If the lender claims that either the pre-bankruptcy claim hasn’t been paid in full, OR, that there are unpaid amounts arising after you filed, they must file a reply.

This call-and-response procedure flushes out any difficulties that show in the lender’s books, and provides a mechanism and a judge to sort things out.

The goal is to exit bankruptcy knowing exactly where you stand on the home loan.

Make sure this happens in your case.

If you change your mind

Things change over time.  If you find that keeping the house no longer fits with your financial future, tell your lawyer immediately.

The confirmed Chapter 13 plan obligates you to make the payments you promised as well as obligating your creditors to stand down.

There’s nothing wrong with changing your mind, so long as you change your Chapter 13 plan to match.

Far too many debtors recently get to the end of the case and get their cases dismissed, without a discharge, because they stopped paying on the mortgage and didn’t alert their lawyer.

More

Make sure you don’t lose house and discharge

Monitoring your mortgage loan 

Before you list your house for sale

 

How To Keep Your House In Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

By

Saving your home ranks high on the list of reasons people file Chapter 13.

The automatic stay stops foreclosures; Chapter 13 gives you time to fix the problem.

Powerful stuff.

But the stay and more time, alone, isn’t enough to save the day if you run afoul of other rules, written and unwritten, about homeownership in Chapter 13.

So, here’s your manual for Keeping Your Home Through Bankruptcy.

Read your Chapter 13 plan

The basic premise of Chapter 13 is that you continue making payments on your home loan during the plan.  Typically, you make the payments that come due after you file, plus catch up on any missed payments via your payments to the Chapter 13 trustee.

In the Bay Area, debtors can choose direct payment or a conduit plan

Every Chapter 13 district does things a little differently  but they all treat post filing payments in one of two ways:

  • either the homeowner makes the payments directly to the mortgage servicer, just as if there were no bankruptcy.
  • or, the on going payments are made to the Chapter 13 trustee, who in turn pays the mortgage servicer. (Those are called conduit payments.)

Make sure you know how it works in your district,  and when your first payment after filing bankruptcy is due.

Keep track of payments you make

Future disputes about whether you made payments directly to the servicer are virtually certain.  Arm yourself with a paper record.

You want your paper trail to be complete and retrievable.  Chances are, the servicer’s records won’t be as good.

I suggest clients pay by personal check (so you get a cancelled check) and transmit that payment by a means that gets you a receipt showing delivery.  With a receipt, you can monitor whether the servicer is promptly crediting your payment, as they are required to do.

Any automatic payments from your bank account or even your ability to pay electronically will undoubtedly be canceled by the servicer.

Compare monthly statements

A new federal rule requires servicers to continue sending you monthly mortgage statements.  That’s a welcome change.

More on the new mortgage statement format

The rule breaks out what is happening with your loan, both as to any pre-bankruptcy default and as to the post-filing payments.

Check out the statements to see if they are consistent, and save them for support in case there’s a dispute in the future.

Watch for payment changes

Your monthly payment on your home loan may change during the Chapter 13.  Escrow amounts for taxes or insurance may change; your loan may have an adjustable rate, or a time-limited interest only feature.

Bankruptcy rule 3002.1 now requires the servicer to give you advance notice of any change in the monthly payment you must make.  If you are in a conduit district, where the trustee makes the on-going payment, ask your attorney how increases in payments are handled.

The rule also requires the servicer to disclose any fees, expenses or charges that it adds to the loan balance during your case.  The disclosure must be made to you, your attorney and the court within 180 days of the expense being incurred.  You have the right to challenge the expense and have a hearing on whether it’s truly owed.

Pay your property taxes

Depending on your loan terms, you may pay property taxes directly to the local taxing authority.  Staying current on property taxes is a condition of being in good standing on your loan.

Know whether your property taxes are escrowed and thus included in your monthly payment, or whether you pay them directly.

If you pay property taxes directly, make it a habit to set aside 1/12th of your annual property taxes when you make your mortgage payment, so you don’t fall behind.

Avoid suffering a motion for relief from stay

The automatic stay is automatic, but it’s not necessarily forever.

If you fail to make required ongoing payments or fail to keep the property insured, the servicer can file a motion asking the court to lift the stay and allow it to foreclose.

More about motions for relief from the stay

Even if you manage to get a deal to cure any defaults, a motion to lift the stay will add to the lender’s attorneys fees, which they will want to collect from you.  And that’s on top of whatever you have to pay your own attorney to protect your property.

Don’t go there:  stay current.

Deduct the mortgage interest you pay

A large part of most mortgage payments is made up of interest on the loan balance.  That interest and any property taxes you pay to the lender are probably tax deductible.  But for reasons I can’t explain, servicers don’t give you a tax form 1098 showing the deductible payments you’ve made or the trustee has made on your behalf.

Follow our how-to on calculating your deduction and assembling the records to support your claimed deduction.  If you don’t do it, you can be sure the IRS won’t do it for you.

Reducing your income tax bill frees up money to make your plan payments.

Heads up and keep your house

This post bankruptcy to-do list isn’t complicated but it is important.  Armed with knowledge of the possible pitfalls, you can head off trouble and sail through Chapter 13.

More

Mistakes that crater Chapter 13 plans

If you can’t make your plan payments

Why discharge gets snatched away at plan’s end

How 13 Works To Save Your House From Foreclosure

By

save house

Saving a house from foreclosure is the single reason most people file bankruptcy.

Bankruptcy stops foreclosure- that’s a given.

But then what?

How can bankruptcy save the house,  rather than just putting off the inevitable loss?

The mortgage lender has a lien on the house, and liens aren’t discharged in bankruptcy.

So, how does bankruptcy help?  Meet Chapter 13 of the Bankruptcy Code.

Chapter 13 bankruptcy is the chapter of choice if your goal is to keep living in the house, as opposed to selling it to realize equity or to avoid the credit hit of a foreclosure.

Chapter 13 imposes a payment plan on lender

Chapter 13 is built to allow the homeowener to cure defaults on long term debts like mortgages.

Gone is the ability of the lender to refuse to take catch-up payments or to insist on cure in a single payment.

This is federal law, and the homeowner is at the helm of this ship.

The homeowner in Chapter 13 proposes a plan for payments to the Chapter 13 trustee.  The trustee, in turn, pays creditors according to the plan.  The usual distribution scheme pays secured claims, like home loans, first.

So, if you are, say, $24,000 behind on your mortgage, your plan can provide that you pay the trustee a monthly payment that catches up on that default.  Chapter 13 plans last a minimum of three years and a maximum of five years.

Your plan will need to provide that you make the on going payments on the mortgage as well.  Each district has its own protocol as to whether you write the check to the mortgage lender for ongoing payments or whether you pay the trustee, who pays the lender.

Once your plan is confirmed, the lender is required to accept the payments.  Absent some post filing breach on your part, the lender is unlikely to have any way to push back against the payment plan.

Trustee challenges to confirmation

Because the confirmed Chapter 13 plan has such power, both the Chapter 13 trustee and the mortgage lender have opportunity and incentive to object to your plan.

coins in a stackThe trustee’s objection is often focused on feasibility.  Does your projected budget show that you can pay enough into the plan to do what’s required?

Remember that the amount necessary to fund the plan is not just the $24,000 that our hypothetical debtor owes on the mortgage.

The Chapter 13 trustee gets a commission on the money she handles in the case.  So, to get $1000 to the mortgage lender, you have to pay the trustee $1100, where the trustee’s commission is the 10% maximum.

Also, if you owe priority taxes, the Bankruptcy Code requires that those taxes be paid in full over the life of the plan.  Likewise,  any delinquent family support claims must be paid in full.

So, the total payments to creditors through the plan may need to cover other creditors as well.

The trustee will look at the total amount your plan provides over the life of the plan and comparing it to your projected income on schedules I and J.  Does it look like you can pay your current living expenses and the amount required by the plan?  If you propose to increase plan payments in future months, is there reason to think you will have the money to do that?

If not, your plan may not be feasible.  If it’s not feasible, it doesn’t get confirmed.

Mortgage creditor fights back

The mortgage creditor has standing to oppose confirmation as well.

Even if the secured creditor doesn’t challenge feasibility or good faith, both required for confirmation, the secured creditor has another, less direct weapon.

When you file bankruptcy, the secured creditor gets to claim not only the missed mortgage payments, but any money the lender has advanced for taxes or insurance.  And, they may have an escrow shortage projected for the current year’s payments.  That’s not to mention foreclosure costs and other fees.

So the lender’s claim may be larger than you expected.

The beauty of Chapter 13 is that the lender has to make full disclosure of those claims and you get to challenge whether the accounting is correct.  You can also challenge whether the fees sought are really allowed by the mortgage.

Mortgage check up at plan’s end

So let’s assume that you get your plan confirmed and faithfully make all the payments required.

New bankruptcy rules work to make sure that you emerge from Chapter 13 fully current on your home loan.

Bankruptcy Rule 3002.1 requires a lender secured by a principal residence to give notice to the court, the trustee and the homeowner of payment changes that occur during the case.

Also, if the required escrow payment changes, or any fees get added to the loan during the case, the lender has to file a notice describing the change.

And the homeowner can challenge changes or additions to the debt.  If it doesn’t get sorted out, a judge will look at the situation and make a ruling.

After the last payment to the plan, if the lender contends you aren’t fully current on the loan, it has to file a detailed accounting showing how much it claims is unpaid.  That accounting is subject to challenge.

Debtor’s rights after 13 is over

mortgage tools for homeownersOne of the few good things included in the 2005 amendments to the Bankruptcy Code, in my opinion, are the provisions that make it a violation of the debtor’s discharge to improperly credit payments made pursuant to a Chapter 13 plan.

All too often, the lender or mortgage servicer either has two sets of books on a loan, or the entries it has made for payments during the plan get altered after the Chapter 13 is over.

Bingo, the lender now claims the borrower is in default, and foreclosure looms.

The bankruptcy court is now a forum for challenging those contentions and getting redress, including the borrower’s attorneys fees to make it happen.

Chapter 13 saves houses

The power of Chapter 13 goes far beyond the automatic stay in giving homeowners a chance to keep their homes.

Not only does it get the homeowner some law to counter balance the endless rights of the lender in the loan documents, it gives the homeowner a referee in the form of a bankruptcy judge who can resolve disputes.

Because bankruptcy judges over the last decade have seen some much of the mortgage meltdown and the deterioration of mortgage servicing up close, they are familiar with the problems and less and less tolerant of lender abuses.

Chapter 13 can be a struggling homeowner’s lucky number.

More

Our best advice on keeping your house

Image copyright Fotolia and Jakub Krechowicz

Tax Deductions Hidden In Chapter 13

By

taxesDon’t miss the tax deductions hiding in your Chapter 13 plan payments.

The same, very important debts that your Chapter 13 plan pays are often tax deductible.

And you are still the person who’s paying, even if the trustee writes the check.

Deductions in bankruptcy

Let’s look at some common deductions lurking in the Chapter 13 disbursements.

Mortgage interest  If your Chapter 13 plan is catching up on delinquent mortgage payments, the claim of the lender is probably mostly interest.

Taxes  Property taxes paid through the plan should be deductible.  Likewise, state income taxes paid by the trustee are deductible.

 Business expenses  If you operate a business in Chapter 13 or operated one before you filed, you may be paying business leases, sales taxes, or vendor debt through the plan.

Get the info you need

In my experience, you have to dig out the information on deductible payments;  I have not seen lenders sending 1098’s reporting mortgage interest paid to debtors when the checks come from the trustee.

Step by step to claiming the mortgage interest deduction

But most if not all Chapter 13 trustees are on the web, and debtors can access the trustees reports of which creditors have been paid this year.

Pull up the report of last year’s disbursements and flag the payments that are deductible.

Save the printout of the trustee’s report in case of question  by the taxing authority.  The IRS will not have gotten a matching report from the lender who got the money and hasn’t reported it to you and the IRS.

How to treat 1099’s on foreclosures and short sales

Go back to prior tax years

If your plan is paying deductible expenses and you’ve been in the bankruptcy case for several years, you may want to look at prior year trustee reports.  Overlooked deductions might justify going back to amend a prior return.

Tax returns are generally amendable for three years.

Check it out

Take this post with a grain of salt, or rather, take it to a tax professional.

I am a bankruptcy lawyer and what I know about taxes, I’ve learned on the job.  But I am convinced that Chapter 13 debtors are missing legitimate tax deductions by overlooking what the Chapter 13 trustee has paid on their behalf.

What your tax professional should know about tax and bankruptcy

Image courtesy of 401(k)calculator.org

How Chapter 13 Saves You Money

By

chapter 13Why should I file Chapter 13  if I have to pay all my creditors in full?

Because, I said, even a 100% repayment plan under Chapter 13 saves you money.

This client had a fistful of equity in a home;  that equity made a Chapter 13 the required choice of chapter for the man.

But he struggled with finding the benefit of using Chapter 13 to manage his debt.

I never would have filed bankruptcy if I realized I had to pay everyone 100%.

So I fired up Excel and crunched numbers to quantify the answer to “why file“.  In this client’s case, the answer was $20,000. 

When asset value drives Chapter 13 payment

Chapter 13 saved $20,000 over 5 years when compared to paying all the creditors what they were owed outside of bankruptcy.

It’s all about the interest rate

At base, the $20,000 bankruptcy savings for this client flowed from the difference between the interest rate in bankruptcy compared to the interest rates on taxes and credit cards in the non-bankruptcy world.

When creditors are entitled to get interest on their claims in bankruptcy, the interest rate that applies is the federal judgment rate.  When I did this exercise, the federal interest rate was 2.35%.  Find today’s judgment rate.

By contrast, I assumed credit card interest rate of 23% and the IRS interest rate to be 6%.

13 crushes credit card debt

Paying the approximately $39,000 in credit cards in 5 years (the same duration as the Chapter 13 plan)  according to contract terms netted the credit card issuers $27,000 in interest!  The total cost to pay off those cards was roughly $69,000.

The cost to pay off the same $39,000 in cards in Chapter 13 was $2250 in interest and $4121 in Chapter 13 trustee commission (assuming the maximum allowed rate of 10% of dollars the trustee receives.)

So, which would you rather pay to keep your house and get rid of your credit cards:  $27,000 or $6365?

Point: Chapter 13

Taxes score a draw

The savings on paying off taxes through Chapter 13 was less dramatic.

We were looking at $46,000 in taxes, some priority, some older than that.  To pay them off outside of bankruptcy would run up about $7300 in interest.

Paying those same taxes in Chapter 13 incurred $2550 in interest. But when you added the trustee’s commission to the bankruptcy interest, the transaction costs essentially equaled the cost of paying the taxes outside of bankruptcy.

Point: neither side

Snoozing creditors lose

The unpredictable further savings may lie in creditor ineptitude.  That’s because only creditors who file a timely proof of claim in a bankruptcy case share in the payments.

In my experience, it’s the rare case when every creditor follows through and files a claim.

So my client will get a discharge of all his liability to creditors who don’t file claims, without paying them a cent.

Point: too soon to tell

Non economic benefits

Here, we looked only at the dollars and cents differences between paying everyone in bankruptcy or outside of bankruptcy.

Not visible in a spreadsheet is the reduced stress that Chapter 13 brings, by corralling all creditors in a single proceeding and having the law to back you up on the schedule on which they are paid.

Stress kills

Chapter 13 keeps you in control of your assets, protected by law, while you pay off what you owe.

 

 

 

 

How Chapter 13 Cuts Car Loan Down To Size

By

car in bankruptcy

Car lenders who make new car loans with an underwater trade-in will face the music in Chapter 13.

The Supreme Court declined to review a 9th Circuit decision that stripped car loans of their protected specially protected status in bankruptcy; as a result, Californians will continue to benefit from the debtor-friendly decision in Penrod, rising out of a San Francisco bankruptcy case.

The question in Penrod

At issue was whether the prohibition on cramming down the debt on a vehicle purchased within 910 days of a bankruptcy filing protected “negative equity” financed in the car purchase.

“Negative equity” is the debt in excess of the trade in’s value. That left-over debt is added to the total of the new car loan and is unrelated to the value of the purchased vehicle.

And BAPCPA, the bankruptcy “reform” act of 2005 prohibited reducing a secured claim on a vehicle purchased within 910 days of the bankruptcy.  But did it similarly protect that part of the loan that wasn’t really related to the cost of the vehicle purchased?

Penrod facts

In Penrod, the Redwood City resident had traded in a car worth $6,000 on which she owed $13,000.  The new car loan included $7000 necessary to pay off the debt on the trade in.

The legal issue is whether that left over debt should enjoy the projections extended car sellers in BAPCPA for purchase money loans on the debtor’s car.

Every other circuit that addressed the question has given purchase money protection to the entire debt including the negative equity portion of the new loan.

The 9th Circuit held the negative equity was not purchase money as to the current car.  The appeals court remanded the case for the bankruptcy court to figure out how to apportion the payments made before bankruptcy between the purchase money element and the leftover debt element.

It’s surprising to me that SCOTUS didn’t accept cert on Penrod, since there is clearly a split among the circuits and it seems to this California bankruptcy lawyer that the Supremes take great pleasure in overturning the 9th Circuit.

But I’ll take a victory however it presents itself and await a decision on how to calculate what can be trimmed from a debtor’s car loan in bankruptcy.

More

How Chapter 13 thwarts repossession

Keeping your car after Chapter 7

10 ways bankruptcy makes you better off

Image  Snackariah under a Creative Commons license

Chapter 13 Dismissed After All Payments Are Made: Self Inflicted Wounds

By

Debtors shoot themselvesThere’s been a rash of bullet-ridden feet lately in Chapter 13 cases.

Debtors seem to whip out their pistols and shoot themselves in the foot with increasing regularity.

Just when their goal of keeping the house was within reach, had they paid attention, they lose it all.

It happens when debtors don’t hold up their end of the bankruptcy bargain.

And at the end of the day, or the end of the plan, they get none of the benefits they sought through bankruptcy.

How does that happen?

Chapter 13 saves houses

The overwhelming majority of Chapter 13 cases in the Bay Area are filed to save a house.

The homeowner needs to catch up on payments, or more frequently, needs a loan modification in order to keep the house.

The Bay Area bankruptcy judges have developed procedures to confirm Chapter 13 plans, and get money flowing out to creditors, while a loan modification is under consideration.  If there is anything we know about loan modifications, it’s that they take time and persistence.

Troubles after the loan modification

One of the provisions of the Chapter 13 plan that the debtor proposes for confirmation by the court addresses how the mortgage lender will be paid while we wait on a loan modification.

The plan might provide that the debtor will make the regular payment, according to the loan terms, directly to the lender in the meantime.

Or, the debtor may propose to make an ongoing payment to the mortgage lender calculated according the the HAMP formula, which says that housing costs should be no more than 31% of a person’s gross income.

So, the HAMP payment to the lender works out to be 31% of monthly income, less property taxes and hazard insurance.

Whichever approach the debtor chooses to deal with the current mortgage payment, it’s set out in the plan, along with the monthly payment the debtor will make to the trustee toward other kinds of debts.

Once a plan is confirmed by the judge, it binds all parties, creditors, trustee and the debtor.  See §1327.

Only some debtors seem to forget their part of this deal.  They don’t make the ongoing payments and don’t modify their plans to match their behavior.

Confirmed plans when loan modification denied

Another variation on our Bay Area plan is the plan provision that says “if I don’t get a loan modification, I will immediately modify the plan or surrender the house”.  I’m paraphrasing the language but the idea is clear:  if I can’t modify the plan, I’ll present an alternative plan to the court.

And then the homeowner doesn’t get a modification, and doesn’t present another plan.

And apparently expects good things to happen despite the failure to live up to his post bankruptcy promises.

Discharge depends on plan performance

The debtor in a Chapter 13 gets a discharge “after completion of all payments under the plan”.  §1328.

The payments “under the plan” include those that the debtor undertook to make directly, rather than through the Chapter 13 trustee.  (In the Northern District of California, we don’t do “conduit plans” where even the post filing mortgage payments are made to the trustee.)

When it comes out that the debtor hasn’t made the on going payments or hasn’t gotten a loan modification, more and more Chapter 13 trustee are recommending that the case be closed without a discharge, since the debtor failed to meet his promises made in bankruptcy.

Ouch!

Candor works

Facing up to a change of heart about a house, or the painful failure to get a loan modification, seems tough at the time.

What debtors seem to be missing is that all the non-house benefits of a bankruptcy discharge are squandered if the Chapter 13 gets closed without discharging those debts.

The other factor that is probably not obvious to the distraught homeowner is that foreclosure does not always follow immediately from the announcement that the debtor elects to surrender the house.

The foreclosure that took forever

Even when we want lenders to foreclose on unwanted property, they don’t.  Or don’t very quickly.

It is not as though the debtor will be immediately homeless if they admit it isn’t working out.

This is my clarion call to debtors:

  • Keep your bankruptcy lawyer in the loop about mortgage payments and loan modifications.
  • Keep a copy of your Chapter 13 plan handy and review what you’ve promised to do in exchange for the protection of the automatic stay and the discharge at the end of the case.

Your lawyer can’t help you if you keep secrets.

More

Roundup of our best advice on keeping your house

 

Protecting Your Co signor When You Can’t Pay

By

cosigned loans

Cosigning a loan links you and your cosignor together for the life of the debt.

If you get in financial trouble, your troubles are your co signor’s troubles too.

If you can’t pay your debts, the standard bankruptcy discharge will get rid of your debt, but it doesn’t help your co signor.

Even while you are protected in bankruptcy by the automatic stay, keeping collectors at bay, and by the discharge at the end of the case, anyone who cosigned for you is exposed.

But Chapter 13 isn’t the “standard” bankruptcy.  It has a special protection for people whose debts are co signed.

Automatic stay covers co signors

Unique to Chapter 13, Section 1301 of the Bankruptcy Code extends the protection of the automatic stay to those who are jointly liable with the debtor on consumer debts.

To qualify, the debt must be for a personal or household purpose.  

So a cosigned car loan is covered;

A cosigned business lease is not.

The benefits of the loan must have flowed to the person who filed bankruptcy.  If you co signed a loan made to a friend, your friend isn’t protected by your Chapter 13 stay.

Finally, to keep the stay in place, the Chapter 13 plan must provide for payment in full of the debt.

Co signed debts get preference

Chapter 13 plans are normally required to treat all unsecured, non priority debts the same.  Each of the general unsecured claims gets the same percentage payment through the plan.

But cosigned debts are excepted.  

The debtor can treat the cosigned debt differently and better than other debts.

It’s OK to separately classify a co signed debt and pay it in full, while other debts get little or nothing in Chapter 13.

So your plan can say:   pay 100% of the allowed claim on the joint credit card claim of BIG BANK, and far less to everyone else.

After the plan is over

The only sticky point for the co signor, who is protected from collection on the co signed debt during the plan, is that interest that may accrue on the debt over the life of the plan.

At the end of the plan, the principal on the debt and any interest owed when the case was filed, will have been paid.  But the bankruptcy case doesn’t stop the accrual of interest at the contract rate during the plan.

The cosignor will remain liable for that interest despite the bankruptcy.

Power of Chapter 13

The co debtor stay and the ability to separately classify co signed debts is just another reason why, as a bankruptcy attorney, I love Chapter 13.

Consider

The secrets of successful Chapter 13 plans

Interviewing a bankruptcy lawyer

Wipe out tax penalties in Chapter 13

At Risk of Repossession? How To Keep The Car & Pay Less

By

car repossessionIf you are one of the  7 million Americans late on your car payments and living in fear that your car will be repossessed, consider how Chapter 13 bankruptcy can save your wheels.

Losing your car can accelerate a torrent of nasty financial consequences.

No car, no way to work.

No work, no income.

So, what can a Chapter 13 bankruptcy do to put you back on the road?

Stop repossession

All chapters of bankruptcy impose an injunction on creditor efforts to collect debts, or enforce liens, automatically when you file.   That automatic stay applies whether or not the creditor knows about it.

So, file bankruptcy and any collection actions taken without court permission are void and legally ineffective.  If they pick up your car after you’ve filed, you can compel its return.

The only exception to the stay applying automatically is if you’ve had two bankruptcy cases dismissed in the past 12 months.  More on multiple dismissals.

Spread out car payments

Chapter 13 allows you to put forward a plan to restructure your car loan.  The remaining payoff balance on your car loan can be spread over 60 months.

Unless your car loan is very new, or the original term very long, that probably lowers what you pay each month through the plan.

Reduce interest rate

You can adjust the interest rate on a car loan paid through the plan to the current day, market rate.  As I write, that interest rate in California is between 4 and 5%.

This power to lower the interest rate is central to a successful readjustment of a high interest car loan.  It’s of little help if your loan is less that today’s market rate.

But Chapter 13 in the states of the 9th Circuit has another trick up its sleeve.

Strip out loan add ons

Part of a Chapter 13 plan can be cutting the car loan down to the portion of the loan that financed the car itself;  you can knock out any part of the loan that paid off an underwater trade-in, or a service contract, or gap insurance.

The 9th Circuit said in Penrod that these additions to the amount financed were not protected by the 2005 bankruptcy amendments that gave special consideration to car lenders.

So, you can pare down the car loan that has to be repaid to just the amount of the loan balance used to buy the car itself, and not all the extras.

Deal with other debts

You don’t just file bankruptcy on one debt; bankruptcy includes all your debts.

Some may be absolutely dischargeable, perhaps without paying anything on them.

Some liens can be wiped out.  Back payments on home loans can be caught up in Chapter 13.

Chances are that there’s more going on in your financial life than just the trouble with  your car loan.

An experienced bankruptcy lawyer can help you look at the big picture and propose a solution to keep you trucking.

More

Your car in Chapter 7 bankruptcy

Is bankruptcy the right choice for you

Interviewing a bankruptcy lawyer

 

 

 

643 Bair Island Road
Suite 403
Redwood City, CA 94063
Phone: (650) 694-4700

Categories