My house is my retirement plan.

If I had a dollar for every time a client said that, I could retire today.

But that approach to funding your old age only works if….

Sell your house to retire

The value in your house makes your balance sheet strong, but doesn’t put food on the table or gas in the car.

That home equity is illiquid.  You can’t write a check against it for the other necessities of life.

To get at that equity, you need to sell the house, or  borrow against it.

A traditional loan requires that you have cash to cover the monthly loan payments.  But hey, you’re not working.  Where does that money come from?

Reverse mortgage

The reverse mortgage was invented to allow seniors who can’t make monthly payments on a conventional loan to access the equity in their home.

But the fact that a reverse mortgage has no monthly payments does not mean that it’s cost free.

No, the interest on the money borrowed accumulates over the life of the borrower.  And the unpaid interest itself earns interest.  The cost is steep.

Dangers in reverse mortgages

And a condition of a reverse mortgage is that you keep up insurance and property taxes.

Real property has carrying costs

Whether encumbered or owned free and clear, real property has its own set of expenses.  Hazard insurance, property taxes, repair and upkeep.

Gotta have cash for those things.  The average Social Security check is about $1300.

Where do you live if you sell

If you’ve benefited from rising home values over your lifetime as a homeowner, the cost to replace the house you’re selling has risen as well.

And buying less house in your community still has the carrying costs we talked about above.

Or you rent.  So housing still has a cost.

Or you move out of the community you live in to somewhere where your sale proceeds go further.

You move away from friends and support systems.  Or maybe you move back to somewhere where you have a support system.  It can work both ways.

Taxes shrink your equity

Capital gain taxes are triggered if you sell your home.  Current tax law excludes from taxable income $250,000 in gain for a single person and $500,000 for a married couple. (Watch for changes, here).

So taxation will deplete your sales proceeds only if you have experienced a lot of appreciation over your lifetime.  But if you’re sitting on lots and lots of equity, count on it shrinking if you sell.

Don’t hide behind your house

There are no easy or universal answers here.  Our lives are longer and our preparation for old age is woefully incomplete.

For too many people I meet, the “home is my retirement account” is an excuse for overpaying for housing at the expense of retirement savings.  It provides cover for failure to set aside any money now.

Diversification of your retirement assets is clearly best.  Have cash and home equity as you age.

But however you are situated, give some clear thought as to how you fund those decades of life when you aren’t working.

More

Do California seniors need bankruptcy

What it costs to retire here

California homestead and senior debt

Image © Fotolia

 

Figuring out what you owe on your home loan can be harder than a calculus exam.

For most people, their mortgage is their biggest debt.  And their home is their most important asset.

Yet, the people accounting for your payments are increasingly incapable of the very basics of their job.

Things have changed since the local bank made you a loan to buy a house and collected the payments you made on that loan.

Now, home loans get sold to someone else the moment the deal closes.  The right to collect the loan payments is bought and sold separately from the right to the payment amount.

And increasingly, the servicers make mistakes as they cut  corners to make a buck.

What do you need to know to assess whether your loan servicer has got the numbers right?

1.  Principal balance isn’t what you owe

Ask someone what they owe on their mortgage and they’ll recite the principal balance.  The principal balance is the remaining part of the amount originally borrowed that is still unpaid.

Yet you may well owe additional sums:  delinquent payments that are mostly interest;  late fees;  escrow advances; or the junk fees that most delinquent loans are larded with.

Finding the principal balance gets trickier yet if the loan has been modified to include a non-interest bearing amount or some other, non standard adjustment.

So the amount necessary to pay off the loan upon sale, or refinance, may well include charges from the past plus fees for calculating what you need to pay to satisfy the debt.

2.  Payments are credited to oldest month unpaid

If you fall behind on a home loan, then resume making payments, your payment is credited to the oldest month still unpaid.

So the payment you make in June may be credited to February.

And the servicer will report that you remain due for June, even though you sent a check in June.  It’s all in the rules about how payments are credited under the terms of the note.

3.  Payments may not be credited

Loan servicers seem to have a separate “pocket” labeled “Suspense”  into which they sometimes dump your payment. They’ve got your money, they just haven’t credited it to the amount you owe.

The only reason for putting funds in suspense that seems justified is when the payment is too little to make a full payment on the loan.  Servicers don’t have to credit partial payments.

So, they put the money in suspense until they receive enough money to make the regular payment.

For reasons no servicer has ever adequately explained, I’ve seen suspense accounts in the tens or even a hundred thousand dollars.

So, a mortgage statement that doesn’t address any funds held in suspense doesn’t tell the whole story.

4.  Escrow accounts contain something extra

If your property taxes and hazard insurance are paid by the lender, you have an escrow account.

Under federal law, the lender is allowed to collect more than the sum of the year’s taxes and insurance as protection against the borrower’s non payment.

The extra money, the “cushion”, can be no more than 1/6 th of the annual expenditures.  It remains your money, it’s just held by the servicer should it have to pay when you haven’t paid.

You should get an annual escrow analysis that shows income and expenses in the past year’s escrow account and a projection of the coming year’s expenses.

That projection will determine what you pay in escrow payments going forward.

5.  Statement doesn’t come from owner of note

Ever since loans were bundled up and sold on Wall Street to investment trusts, the work of collecting your payments has been handed off to loan “servicers”.

The owner of the note pays a company to deposit your payments, keep track of fees and expenses, and take action if you don’t pay.

The servicer seldom owns the note, they just own the right to collect the money.

And servicers change.  Sometimes as often as we change the oil in our car.

When there’s a loan handoff from one servicer to a new servicer, details about anything unusual in the loan account sometimes get lost.

Get behind the monthly statement

The problem of finding out what the servicer thinks you owe became such a problem that regulations written pursuant to the Dodd-Frank act gave borrowers some clout.

Now, a borrower with a home loan can make a Request For Information about their loan and expect answers within a shorter period than under the old law.

If the servicing of the loan has changed hands, the borrower has a window in which to request information from the old servicer, to compare with what the new servicer thinks.

Find the “how-to” for a Request for Information.

More

Your mortgage and your credit report after Chapter 13

Bad mortgage accounting violates your Chapter 13 discharge

Get tax credit for curing mortgage defaults in Chapter 13

How Chapter 13 works

 

 

 

 

 

How can you pay thousands of dollars in mortgage payments in a year, and get a  tax Form 1098 for a fraction of actual mortgage interest paid?

That’s what my client wanted to know.

His monthly mortgage payment is $2715.  The loan is currently interest only.  All the payments were made.

And yet, the Form 1098 from PNC says the year’s mortgage interest paid is only $1800.

So what happened to the other $30,780?  That’s a lot of money to go missing.

Welcome to the further screwed up world of mortgage loan servicing.

The short answer right now to the question I posed at the top is I don’t know yet.

But here’s what I suspect. [Read more…]

Is your Chapter 13 plan  paying back mortgage payments that were delinquent when you filed bankruptcy?

If so, a tax deduction lurks, unclaimed, in the trustee’s records.

Track down that tax deduction and you reduce your federal income tax burden.

But it’s difficult because, for reasons I have not been able to figure out, the lenders don’t send IRS form 1098’s to either you or the trustee for mortgage interest paid through the plan.

So you don’t have proof that mortgage interest was paid, and neither does the IRS.

But, we can fix that.  I recently had occasion to walk a client through the process of figuring out the mortgage interest paid by the trustee.

I’ll retrace my steps and you can see how I figured out that he’d paid some $50,000 in mortgage interest  over the years of his plan that he hadn’t yet claimed on his taxes.

1.  Find the interest element in the lender’s proof of claim.

To be paid through a Chapter 13 plan, the lender must file a proof of claim on official form B410.  The mortgage attachment to that form, B410A has a line in Part 2 for “interest due”.

That line shows us what part of the missed payments, as of the filing of the bankruptcy case, was made up of mortgage interest.

2.  Calculate what percentage of the arrears is mortgage interest.

Part 3 of the mortgage attachment form breaks out the elements in the lender’s claim in the bankruptcy.  We need to know what fraction of the total claim the trustee will be paying is interest.

Take the “interest due” amount you located in Step 1 and divide it by the total at the foot of Part 3.

That’s the percentage of the total claim of the lender that’s interest.

3.  Access the Chapter 13 trustee’s site for payments to mortgage creditor

Chapter 13 trustees use different software to account for their operations.  You should have received information at the beginning of your case on accessing information about your payments and the trustee’s disbursements.

If you need help with the trustee’s web site, call the trustee’s office for help.

On the trustee’s site for your case, find the claim filed by the mortgage lender.  There should be a list of the date and amount of each payment made to the creditor on account of your mortgage arrears.

Total the payments for the last calendar year and multiple that total by the percentage of the claim that is interest, from Step 2 above.

Bingo! you have the number that represents what the trustee paid your creditor in mortgage interest for that calendar year.

Tax accounting rough and dirty

Your figure for mortgage interest paid in a year is an approximation.  By the end of the plan, the amount of interest paid will equal the amounts you’ve calculated this way.

The creditor may have applied it to your account differently.  Mortgage loan servicing is so erratic and inaccurate these days that it’s hard to tell.

If this calculation is off, it probably underestimates the amount of interest in the early payments from the trustee.  Most mortgages require the lender to apply payments first to interest, then to principal, then to expenses.  My experience is that they seldom follow the rules.

If anyone objects to your calculation, make them propose a better one.  Or make the recipient of the mortgage interest account for it in the usual way.

Save your work

Outside of bankruptcy, the lender would send you and the IRS a copy of their report on Form 1098 for mortgage interest you paid during the tax year.

We’ve done this sleuthing because they didn’t tell either the IRS or you what you paid in mortgage interest.

So, you may have to show the IRS how you got to a deduction that doesn’t appear in their records.

Print or save to pdf each of the documents you used to make your calculation.  You want to be able to support the deduction if challenged.

Another path to tax deduction

Alternatively, you could use the Request for Information process found in RESPA to ask the servicer of your loan how much interest you paid in a calendar year.

Servicers are required to provide answers about loan servicing within 30 business days of your request.  Requests must be in writing and contain identifying information.  More on how to make a Request for Information.

Amend earlier returns

Federal tax law allows you to amend tax returns for three years from filing.  There’s an IRS publication for amending returns.

You can calculate what you paid through the Chapter 13 plan for prior tax years and amend those returns to claim this deduction.

Gather your calculator and get on the trail of these illusive, but valuable, mortgage interest deductions.