• Home
  • Bankruptcy in Brief
  • ABC’s of Bankruptcy
  • Considering Bankruptcy
  • True Stories
  • Chapter 13
  • Blog
  • About
  • TOC

Northern California Bankruptcy Lawyer

On The Bankruptcy Soapbox

The Soap Box
  • How bankruptcy works
  • Mortgage Matters
  • Consumer Rights
  • You & Your Lawyer
  • Small Business
  • Family Law

The Reverse Side Of The Coin: In Re Welsh

By Cathy Moran

flip sideJust because debtors can keep their upscale trappings and their toys bought on credit doesn’t mean they should.

I share bankruptcy attorney Jon Brooks’ excitement over the 9th Circuit’s recent decision in Welsh.  

The appeals court held that a debtor wasn’t guilty of bad faith in proposing a Chapter 13 plan that kept and paid for what the bankruptcy trustee claimed  were non essential items.

You can keep them

The Welsh debtors proposed to pay on their existing secured debt for a third car their daughter drove; a house expensive by local standards; 2 ATV’s; and a recreation trailer.

The 9th Circuit said that was fine in light of the way Congress fashioned the means test that was added to bankruptcy law in 2005.

I’m delighted to have a clear statement that Chapter 13 relief is open to people with upscale houses or wheels.

To overlay the means test with the subjective inquiry of is this house too grand? or should a debtor get to keep his boat? just defeats the objectivity that the means test was supposed to implement.

Our economy isn’t well served if the trustees and courts can impose their personal standards on how well a debtor can live and qualify for relief in bankruptcy.  That would be a recipe for chaos in the bankruptcy courts.

It would be particularly ironic if the very lenders who lobbied (and paid) Congress so hard for bankruptcy laws that made it harder to get a discharge found the law applied to make willing borrowers stop paying on secured debt.

But should you

But just because paying for a second home or an RV is permitted in Chapter 13, that doesn’t mean that bankruptcy attorneys should acquiesce.  Often the strain of paying for those extras is what landed individuals in a bankruptcy lawyer’s office in the first place.

One of bankruptcy’s real strengths is the opportunity for a financial do over:  a chance to escape the consequences of bad decisions.

Sure, in a perfect world, we’d all like to keep those things that make life nicer or more fun.  But how does the associated expense play into the bigger financial picture.

My first question to clients inclined to keep the toys or the marginal investment property is  what do you have saved for retirement?  Shoulder to shoulder with the student loan crisis is the systemic under preparation of Americans for a dignified and independent retirement.

 Chapter 13 is a chance to make better financial choices.  What the debtor who commits to paying for all the encumbered “stuff” through a Chapter 13 plan doesn’t grasp is that the secured debts are paid first.  If the plan craters mid way and there is other non dischargeable debt, like taxes or family support, the lender on the toys has gotten paid, but Uncle Sam hasn’t.

So, a rousing cheer for the 9th Circuit, and down with the life-style police in bankruptcy robes, but let’s not lose sight of the big picture about financial stability and a real fresh start.

Image courtesy of Wikimedia 

 

More from the Soapbox

  • Loan Modification Excuses No Longer Good With CourtsLoan Modification Excuses No Longer Good With Courts
  • What T-Boz Missed When Chapter 13 DismissedWhat T-Boz Missed When Chapter 13 Dismissed
  • Bankruptcy and the “hard of hearing”Bankruptcy and the “hard of hearing”
  • Bankruptcy Alphabet:  Y is for YokeBankruptcy Alphabet: Y is for Yoke
  • Give More Than ThanksGive More Than Thanks

Filed Under: How bankruptcy works

About Cathy Moran

I'm a veteran bankruptcy lawyer and consumer advocate in California's Silicon Valley. I write, teach, and speak in the hopes of expanding understanding of how bankruptcy can make life better in a family's future.

Bankruptcy Basics

About The Soapbox

You’ve arrived at the Bankruptcy Soapbox, a resource of bankruptcy information and consumer law.

Soapbox is a companion site to Bankruptcy in Brief, where I try to be largely explanatory and even handed (Note I said “try”).

Here, I allow myself to tell stories and express strong opinions. We dig deeper into how to consider bankruptcy and navigate a bankruptcy case.

Moran Law Group
Bankruptcy specialists for individuals and small businesses in the San Francisco Bay Area

How Bankruptcy Works

What Happens To Your Bank Account in Chapter 13

Those considering filing a Chapter 13 bankruptcy worry about "what happens to my bank account?" Will the trustee take all the money? How do I pay my living expenses after I file? The short answer is: nothing changes. The account remains yours and available for all the expenses of day to day living. Because, … Read more

More Posts from this Category

643 Bair Island Road
Suite 403
Redwood City, CA 94063
Phone: (650) 694-4700
Phone: (650) 368-4700

Categories

All content copyright © Moran Law Group. All rights reserved.