• Home
  • Bankruptcy in Brief
  • ABC’s of Bankruptcy
  • Considering Bankruptcy
  • True Stories
  • Chapter 13
  • Blog
  • About
  • TOC

Northern California Bankruptcy Lawyer

On The Bankruptcy Soapbox

The Soap Box
  • How bankruptcy works
  • Mortgage Matters
  • Consumer Rights
  • You & Your Lawyer
  • Small Business
  • Family Law

Glimmer of Hope For Change In Student Loan Dischargeability

By Cathy Moran

student loan door opening

A small opening in the legal barrier to discharging student loans in bankruptcy has appeared in a case called Roth.

To discharge a student loan in bankruptcy, the borrower must show that repayment of the loan would cause he and his dependents undue hardship.

The test for what constitutes “undue hardship”  is many circuits the Brunner test:

  • repaying the student loan would keep the borrower from a minimal standard of living
  • the conditions that prevent repayment are likely to continue for the foreseeable future
  • the borrow has made a good faith effort to repay the loan

In short, the bar is very high and as a result, student loans, no matter how burdensome or unwise, usually survive a bankruptcy discharge.

Many bankruptcy judges, confronted with very sad and hopeless situations involving student loans, have regretfully  declared themselves bound by the 25 year old test crafted in Brunner.

Roth opens the door

Along comes the Roth decision of the 9th Circuit Bankruptcy Appellate Panel.  The good news is that the appeals panel overturned the decision of the trial court and permitted the discharge of  Ms. Roth’s student loans.

The better news is found in Chief Judge Jim Pappas’ concurrence, which roundly calls for the 9th Circuit to revisit and revise the Brunner test.

the analysis required by Pena/Brunner to determine the existence of an undue hardship is
too narrow, no longer reflects reality, and should be revised by the Ninth Circuit when it has the opportunity to do so. Put simply, in this era, bankruptcy courts should be free to consider the totality of a debtor’s circumstances in deciding whether a discharge of student loan debt for undue hardship is warranted.

Pappas contrasts the changes in the law governing the  dischargeability of student loans since Brunner was written.

When  Brunner was decided, a student loan could be discharged with no more showing than that it had been in pay status for five years.  Alternatively, the borrower could show that repayment would cause undue hardship.

Quite a different world from today, when student loans of whatever age are dischargeable only on a showing of undue hardship, using a test crafted for another time and another legal circumstance.

We can hope that Pappas’s analysis of the [dis]utility of the old test in a new world will prod other judges, and more importantly, other circuits, to revisit and revise Brunner.

The stakes are huge.

Image credit:  © Ilona Baha – Fotolia.com

More from the Soapbox

  • Research bankruptcy on the internetResearch bankruptcy on the internet
  • Try The Community Property Two StepTry The Community Property Two Step
  • What’s So Scary About Bankruptcy?What’s So Scary About Bankruptcy?
  • Automatic Stay Has Exceptions: It Doesn’t Stop EverythingAutomatic Stay Has Exceptions: It Doesn’t Stop Everything
  • Mortgage Modification and Moral HazardMortgage Modification and Moral Hazard

Filed Under: Developing law

About Cathy Moran

I'm a veteran bankruptcy lawyer and consumer advocate in California's Silicon Valley. I write, teach, and speak in the hopes of expanding understanding of how bankruptcy can make life better in a family's future.

Bankruptcy Basics

About The Soapbox

You’ve arrived at the Bankruptcy Soapbox, a resource of bankruptcy information and consumer law.

Soapbox is a companion site to Bankruptcy in Brief, where I try to be largely explanatory and even handed (Note I said “try”).

Here, I allow myself to tell stories and express strong opinions. We dig deeper into how to consider bankruptcy and navigate a bankruptcy case.

Moran Law Group
Bankruptcy specialists for individuals and small businesses in the San Francisco Bay Area

How Bankruptcy Works

What Happens To Your Bank Account in Chapter 13

Those considering filing a Chapter 13 bankruptcy worry about "what happens to my bank account?" Will the trustee take all the money? How do I pay my living expenses after I file? The short answer is: nothing changes. The account remains yours and available for all the expenses of day to day living. Because, … Read more

More Posts from this Category

643 Bair Island Road
Suite 403
Redwood City, CA 94063
Phone: (650) 694-4700
Phone: (650) 368-4700

Categories

All content copyright © Moran Law Group. All rights reserved.