Northern California Bankruptcy Lawyer

On The Bankruptcy Soapbox

The Soap Box

Your Right To Credit Reporting After Bankruptcy

By

 

credit report after bankruptcy

You’ve finished your Chapter 13 and emerged from bankruptcy with your home loan current.

But your credit report is a blank page as to your mortgage.

The mortgage servicer isn’t reporting your payments to the credit reporting agencies [CRA’s].  

Nothing. Nada.  Crickets.

So, even though you’re making regular payments, you’re not visibly rebuilding your credit.

Ask the servicer and they’ll tell you that they can’t report your payments “because of your bankruptcy discharge“.

But they are wrong:  a little-discussed provision of Chapter 13 says that long-term mortgage debt is not discharged in 13.

Yup.  The mortgage loan is not discharged as a personal obligation.

And therefore, there is no bar to the servicer reporting your payments, and every danger should they not report.

Servicer’s obligation to report

Put simply, if a creditor reported to credit reporting agencies  before the bankruptcy was filed, then there is an obligation to report after the bankruptcy.  The “furnisher”, the creditor who supplies information to the credit reporting agency, has an obligation to make the information on file fully accurate.

In contrast to an unsecured debt like a credit card, which should be reported as having a zero balance after the discharge, the mortgage loan after Chapter 13 has a balance.

Presumably, it is also current.  Both facts which should appear on your credit report.

Mortgages excluded from Chapter 13 discharge

I’m certain you will have to cite to bankruptcy law when you challenge the improper reporting on a mortgage loan after Chapter 13.

Here’s the part of the Bankruptcy Code that excludes long term debt like your mortgage.

Section 1328 says,

(a)… the court shall grant the debtor a discharge of all debts provided for by the plan …, except any debt—

(1)provided for under section 1322(b)(5); 

 Section 1322(b), that §1328 refers to,  says

(b)Subject to subsections (a) and (c) of this section, the plan may—

(5) … provide for the curing of any default within a reasonable time and maintenance of payments while the case is pending on any unsecured claim or secured claim on which the last payment is due after the date on which the final payment under the plan is due;

Get mortgage payments reported

If you find that your post discharge payments on your home loan aren’t being reported, challenge the accuracy of what is on your report about that loan with the credit reporting agency.

It is the CRA’s responsibility to see that information in your credit file is accurate.  The CRA is supposed to ask the furnisher to reinvestigate the challenged tradeline.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has a how-to, with a template letter, on how to dispute inaccurate information on your credit report.

Get the good information reported.

More

How to find and fix credit reporting errors

Your post bankruptcy to-do list

7 Keys To Keeping Your House: Chapter 13 After You File

By

keep the house

Filing Chapter 13 bankruptcy stops the foreclosure.  You’ve protected your home, for the moment.

Bankruptcy gets you a sheltered legal environment to address the problems with your mortgage.

You heave a sigh of relief.

But the fight to keep your house isn’t over, just because there’s a stay.  You’ve just gotten through the first round.

You need to stay on your toes for the balance of the match to emerge with your house safe at the end of your bankruptcy.

Here’s what you need to know.

Mortgage lenders get special consideration

In the bankruptcy context,  the mortgage lender gets privileged treatment.

Anglo Saxon law, from which US law is drawn, has long given particular protection to the claims of property owners.  After all, it was those who owned property who wrote the laws.

The mortgage lender gets that special treatment because the lender’s lien is a property interest in your home.

That lien entitles the lender to regular payments;  if payments aren’t made, the lender can ask for relief from stay to foreclose.

The exception is if the value of the collateral is less than the total of the liens ahead of the lien in question.  Think:  underwater second mortgage.

Follow these 7 keys for keeping your house AND getting a discharge in Chapter 13.

1.  Regular mortgage payments required

Most Chapter 13 plans provide that the trustee pays the arrears on your mortgage, while you make the payments that come due after filing.

Make the payments- that means property taxes and insurance as well.

Too often, homeowners get fixated on paying the arrearages on their mortgage that they overlook, or struggle, with the ongoing payments.

Court are intolerant of borrowers who want the protection of the bankruptcy stay, but don’t take seriously their obligation to pay the monthly payments that come due after filing.

That intolerance spills over into dismissal of  Chapter 13 cases without a discharge when debtors fail to make current payments.

2.  Look for other liens

Chapter 13 isn’t limited to fixing problems with mortgage liens.  Your plan can either avoid altogether or reduce the amount of tax or judgment liens,

Make sure that you check the public record to see if any avoidable liens have attached, unnoticed, to your home.

If you find liens, your plan can cut them down to size.

3.  Pursue modification

Your best bet may be to agree with the lender on a modification of your mortgage.  Nothing in Chapter 13 stops the parties from considering modification.

Northern California bankruptcy judges have decreed that negotiations for a modification do not violate the automatic stay

Frequently, the modified mortgage either folds the arrears into the loan balance, to be paid over the life of the loan. Or, modification designates a portion of the amount owed as not bearing interest, but payable at loan-end or sale.

A modification that cures the arrears may eliminate the mortgage arrears portion of a Chapter 13 monthly payment, thereby increasing the chances of success.

4.  Review the lender’s claim

In order to be paid in a Chapter 13, a creditor must file a proof of claim.  For mortgages secured by the debtor’s principal residence, a detailed attachment is required.

The mortgage attachment must account for payments and charges to the loan from the date of the first, uncured default.

The POC also contains an analysis of any escrowed taxes and insurance, and the adequacy of the monthly payment to pay those expenses.

Dig into these numbers and see if they match your payment records and whether they are otherwise complete.

There’s lots of data there, some of it correct and some woefully wrong.

5.  Keep records of  your payments

Too many mortgage servicers fail the fundamental task of accepting your payments and crediting them properly.

The method of accounting changes with bankruptcy:  payments made after filing are supposed to be credited to a separate accounting for your loan, while the pre bankruptcy record stands alone

Servicers don’t always do that.  Payments sometimes sit for months on someone’s desk, undeposited.

I tell clients to pay with paper checks on their accounts and send the payment by a method that gets you a receipt upon delivery to the servicer.

It’s a hassle, I know, but you end up with a record from your bank that the check was cashed, and you have proof that it was delivered.  The added expense is nothing to the cost of your attorney having to track down the facts showing you paid.

6.  Read payment change notices

If your monthly mortgage payment changes after you file bankruptcy, the servicer must send you a Notice Of Payment Change.

The change may be driven by an interest rate change or a change in the cost of escrowed taxes or insurance.

Even though it comes on a court form, and looks dense, you’ve got to read it and adjust your post filing payments on your mortgage accordingly.

If you’re uncertain, ask your lawyer.

7.  Exploit case-end rules

When you’ve made your last payment to the trustee, bankruptcy rules require a notice to the mortgage servicer about the state of your loan balance.

If the lender claims that either the pre-bankruptcy claim hasn’t been paid in full, OR, that there are unpaid amounts arising after you filed, they must file a reply.

This call-and-response procedure flushes out any difficulties that show in the lender’s books, and provides a mechanism and a judge to sort things out.

The goal is to exit bankruptcy knowing exactly where you stand on the home loan.

Make sure this happens in your case.

If you change your mind

Things change over time.  If you find that keeping the house no longer fits with your financial future, tell your lawyer immediately.

The confirmed Chapter 13 plan obligates you to make the payments you promised as well as obligating your creditors to stand down.

There’s nothing wrong with changing your mind, so long as you change your Chapter 13 plan to match.

Far too many debtors recently get to the end of the case and get their cases dismissed, without a discharge, because they stopped paying on the mortgage and didn’t alert their lawyer.

More

Make sure you don’t lose house and discharge

Monitoring your mortgage loan 

Before you list your house for sale

 

The Foreclosure That Was Longer Than War & Peace

By

Fotolia_94610869_XS_opt

Foreclosure is coming.  Whether by choice or circumstances, you know the bank will take the house.

Should you start packing immediately?

The way banks are currently operating, the answer is:  not yet, not soon, not for a long time.

For one of my clients, the answer to how long was well more than 735 days.  And they did nothing to delay the inevitable.

Here’s the foreclosure timeline for this California couple.

A year of missed payments

When they filed bankruptcy in June, 2013, they were 13 months behind on their mortgage.  That’s 390 days without paying.

The house was waaaaay underwater and they decided upfront to let it go.  And said so in the Chapter 13 plan.

From bankruptcy filing to relief from stay

It took 477 days from the commencement of the bankruptcy case for the lender to request and get an order from the bankruptcy court permitting them to foreclose.

Court order til foreclosure

It took another 180 days to actually conduct a  sale.  At that point, the lender owned the house, but the couple was still living there.

Sale to eviction

Then, remarkably, another 271 days went by before the bank took steps to evict the former owners from the house that it had owned for more than 8 months.  And the bank paid the former owners some cash to move out voluntarily.

Your mileage may vary

The experience of this couple doesn’t assure you of a mortgage servicer with a similarly lackadaisical approach.  But it is consistent with the data on California foreclosure.

The takeaway is:  don’t move out until you absolutely have to.

Living rent free til the foreclosure allows you to build up a kitty to finance the move.  Or feed your retirement fund.  Or start saving for a new house.

More:

Get paid to surrender possession

Your rights while you’re in foreclosure

Buying a house after foreclosure

Basics of California foreclosure

How To Keep Your House In Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

By

Saving your home ranks high on the list of reasons people file Chapter 13.

The automatic stay stops foreclosures; Chapter 13 gives you time to fix the problem.

Powerful stuff.

But the stay and more time, alone, isn’t enough to save the day if you run afoul of other rules, written and unwritten, about homeownership in Chapter 13.

So, here’s your manual for Keeping Your Home Through Bankruptcy.

Read your Chapter 13 plan

The basic premise of Chapter 13 is that you continue making payments on your home loan during the plan.  Typically, you make the payments that come due after you file, plus catch up on any missed payments via your payments to the Chapter 13 trustee.

In the Bay Area, debtors can choose direct payment or a conduit plan

Every Chapter 13 district does things a little differently  but they all treat post filing payments in one of two ways:

  • either the homeowner makes the payments directly to the mortgage servicer, just as if there were no bankruptcy.
  • or, the on going payments are made to the Chapter 13 trustee, who in turn pays the mortgage servicer. (Those are called conduit payments.)

Make sure you know how it works in your district,  and when your first payment after filing bankruptcy is due.

Keep track of payments you make

Future disputes about whether you made payments directly to the servicer are virtually certain.  Arm yourself with a paper record.

You want your paper trail to be complete and retrievable.  Chances are, the servicer’s records won’t be as good.

I suggest clients pay by personal check (so you get a cancelled check) and transmit that payment by a means that gets you a receipt showing delivery.  With a receipt, you can monitor whether the servicer is promptly crediting your payment, as they are required to do.

Any automatic payments from your bank account or even your ability to pay electronically will undoubtedly be canceled by the servicer.

Compare monthly statements

A new federal rule requires servicers to continue sending you monthly mortgage statements.  That’s a welcome change.

More on the new mortgage statement format

The rule breaks out what is happening with your loan, both as to any pre-bankruptcy default and as to the post-filing payments.

Check out the statements to see if they are consistent, and save them for support in case there’s a dispute in the future.

Watch for payment changes

Your monthly payment on your home loan may change during the Chapter 13.  Escrow amounts for taxes or insurance may change; your loan may have an adjustable rate, or a time-limited interest only feature.

Bankruptcy rule 3002.1 now requires the servicer to give you advance notice of any change in the monthly payment you must make.  If you are in a conduit district, where the trustee makes the on-going payment, ask your attorney how increases in payments are handled.

The rule also requires the servicer to disclose any fees, expenses or charges that it adds to the loan balance during your case.  The disclosure must be made to you, your attorney and the court within 180 days of the expense being incurred.  You have the right to challenge the expense and have a hearing on whether it’s truly owed.

Pay your property taxes

Depending on your loan terms, you may pay property taxes directly to the local taxing authority.  Staying current on property taxes is a condition of being in good standing on your loan.

Know whether your property taxes are escrowed and thus included in your monthly payment, or whether you pay them directly.

If you pay property taxes directly, make it a habit to set aside 1/12th of your annual property taxes when you make your mortgage payment, so you don’t fall behind.

Avoid suffering a motion for relief from stay

The automatic stay is automatic, but it’s not necessarily forever.

If you fail to make required ongoing payments or fail to keep the property insured, the servicer can file a motion asking the court to lift the stay and allow it to foreclose.

More about motions for relief from the stay

Even if you manage to get a deal to cure any defaults, a motion to lift the stay will add to the lender’s attorneys fees, which they will want to collect from you.  And that’s on top of whatever you have to pay your own attorney to protect your property.

Don’t go there:  stay current.

Deduct the mortgage interest you pay

A large part of most mortgage payments is made up of interest on the loan balance.  That interest and any property taxes you pay to the lender are probably tax deductible.  But for reasons I can’t explain, servicers don’t give you a tax form 1098 showing the deductible payments you’ve made or the trustee has made on your behalf.

Follow our how-to on calculating your deduction and assembling the records to support your claimed deduction.  If you don’t do it, you can be sure the IRS won’t do it for you.

Reducing your income tax bill frees up money to make your plan payments.

Heads up and keep your house

This post bankruptcy to-do list isn’t complicated but it is important.  Armed with knowledge of the possible pitfalls, you can head off trouble and sail through Chapter 13.

More

Mistakes that crater Chapter 13 plans

If you can’t make your plan payments

Why discharge gets snatched away at plan’s end

Make Sure Your Mortgage Is Current At Bankruptcy’s End

By

maze-1804499_1280_opt

 

What do you really owe on your home mortgage when you get to the end of your Chapter 13 case?

For years, homeowners couldn’t tell where they were or how to get answers.

But with the recent changes to bankruptcy rules, you don’t have to wonder where you stand with your mortgage lender.

  • Are you really, fully current with the mortgage?
  • Are there fees and charges that you don’t know about?
  • Are you ready to emerge from bankruptcy 100% paid up?
  • Is the lender really poised to start foreclosure?

Starting December 1, 2016, your Chapter 13 trustee is required to flush out any surprises that lurk in your home loan servicer’s accounts.

And a federal judge stands by to sort it out.

When my client’s Chapter 13 case was through,  she was $62,000 better off, because of the rule.

Let’s hear it for Bankruptcy Rule 3002.1.

Why we needed this rule

Rule 3002.1 addresses the lack of transparency that used to exist about your home loan during a Chapter 13.

The Chapter 13 runs 3 to 5 years, and the automatic stay limits the lender’s ability to let you know what’s happening with the loan.  (This assumes that the lender ever really wanted to let you know what’s happening, but that’s another rant, another day.)

Lots can happen during those years. Too often, before the rule, debtors would get their Chapter 13 discharge and a foreclosure notice practically in the same day’s mail.

It might be late fees, forced placed insurance, or just plain accounting mistakes.  Whatever the reason, the consequences were horrific.

What the rule does

If your Chapter 13 plan provides for payment on your home mortgage, your lender (or the servicer for the lender) must give certain notices to you, the court, and the trustee during the case.

First, they must file a notice if the payment amount changes during the case.  The notice must be given at least 21 days before the change takes place.

Second, they must file a notice of any fees, expenses or charges added to the loan balance that were incurred after the case was filed.  The notice must be given within 180 days of the time when the charge was incurred.

If you dispute that the charge is allowable, you have a year from the filing of the notice to file a motion and schedule a hearing before the court about the charge.

Current at case end

When you’ve made the last payment to your Chapter 13 plan, the trustee must file a notice of final cure payment and send the notice to you, your attorney, and the creditor.

The notice says that the trustee believes you to have cured any pre bankruptcy default and alleges that you are fully current with payments and fees that came due after you filed.

The mortgage lender must file a responsive pleading within 21 days.  If the lender claims that there are unpaid amounts, they must itemize the fees and expenses that they claim are still outstanding in a payment history.

Bingo:  you have visibility.  And you have a right to file a motion before the court to determine if you’ve cured the default and paid everything that is required of you afterwards.

If the lender screwed up

Chances are pretty high that the servicer has screwed up.  Often that takes the form of failure to have given you timely notice of fees added to the loan.  Remember, notice must be given within 180 days of when the fees were incurred.

If the lender has failed to give proper notice, the judge can bar the lender from offering evidence in the hearing to determine if you’re current and can award you your attorneys fees caused by the failure.

The rule in action

A lender’s failure to follow the rule in the case of one of my clients resulted in the lender having to forgive some $62,000 in post filing fees and taxes they’d paid without telling my client.  In addition, they paid my fees for getting the charges  wiped out.

You can read the court’s opinion with the details of each blunder the bank made.

I believe that such results are just the tip of the iceberg in this field.

Get through the maze

The beauty of Rule 3002.1 is that it gets to the heart of your dealings with your home mortgage lender while you still have access to a bankruptcy judge to make things right.

It’s up to you and your attorney to see that the trustee gives the required notice.  If the trustee doesn’t, the debtor can.

Then you need analyze the response of the lender and challenge behavior that isn’t compliant with the law.

Don’t miss out on getting all the relief that Chapter 13 entitles you to.

More

RESPA to the rescue:  send information

Mortgage statements after bankruptcy

What’s discharged in a bankruptcy

 

No Foreclosure If Loan Modification In Process

By

 

foreclosure roofline 650 taberandrew

The cruelest trick played on homeowners trying to modify their mortgage was dual tracking.

One side of the bank assured the borrower that their loan modification application was being considered and they didn’t need to worry.

All the while, the other side of the bank was conducting a foreclosure sale.

The borrower wakes up to find that they are no longer homeowners.

No more.

New federal rules prohibit dual tracking

Mortgage lenders are now prohibited by federal law from conducting a foreclosure while a mortgage modification application is under consideration.

Regulation X – Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act

Before a foreclosure is begun, the lender or their servicer must take steps to let the borrower know what options exist to keep the house.  The mandated timeline creates a four month interval between delinquency and starting the foreclosure in which alternatives can be explored.

Live contact with borrower

Mortgage servicers must attempt to make live contact with borrowers who become delinquent within 36 days of the delinquency.  A voicemail message doesn’t cut it.  Reg. X §1024.39

The servicer must describe the kinds of loss mitigation options that are available and they must establish a single point of contact for the borrower with the servicer.  Reg. X § 1024.40

No foreclosure can be instituted until 120 days have passed from the first delinquency.  More importantly, if a complete loan modification application has been submitted to the the servicer by the 120 day point, no foreclosure can be begun.  Reg. X §1024.41

Last minute help

If the borrower misses the 120 day deadline for submitting a loan modification application, there’s still protection in the new rules.

If a loan mod application is made more than 37 days before the foreclosure sale, the servicer cannot conduct a foreclosure sale until it issues a decision on the application.

The new rules deal with a myriad of variations on these timelines.  The theme in the rules is consistent:  federal law requires a decision on a loan modification application before the foreclosure train chugs down that track.

If the servicer breaks the rules

The new rules have teeth.

Borrowers who believe their servicer has failed to follow the rules can sue the servicer.  If you can prove your case, you can collect your actual damages as a result of the violation; your costs of suit; and your attorneys’ fees.

These regulations implement provisions of the Dodd Frank legislation; they became effective January 10, 2014.

Another arrow in homeowner’s quiver

These rules do not preempt other rights that homeowner’s have in this arena that give them greater rights.

Like any new law, we will have to see how they work over time.

While the rules don’t require servicers to modify loans, they do require servicers to refrain from foreclosing while a loan modification application is pending.

Image courtesy flickr and taberandrew.

No House, No Discharge When Chapter 13 Goes Off Script

By

 

Chapter 13 alarm

Sound the alarm.

What began as a trickle of Chapter 13 cases ending badly has become a torrent.

More and more, bankruptcy judges are strictly enforcing the direct pay term of Chapter 13 plans:

If your plan says you will pay your on-going mortgage payments directly, and you don’t pay as promised, the judge may dismiss your case without a discharge.

How discharge differs from dismissal

After three to five years in bankruptcy, you end up with neither house nor a discharge of your debts.

Bummer!

Chapter 13 plans have teeth

Here’s why failing to follow through on your plan can be fatal.

The Chapter 13 plan becomes a court order when it’s confirmed by the court.  It requires the creditors to wait for their money, sets out the payments to be made, and binds all parties to its terms.

In many districts, the trustee pays any arrearages on home mortgages, but the debtor pays the mortgage payments directly that come due during the plan.

But all too often, the debtor stops making the on-going payments to the mortgage lender, without telling any of the other interested parties, like their attorney, the trustee, and the court.

The lack of payments goes unremarked. 

Checklist for keeping your house and your discharge

But with the advent of Rule 3002.1, there’s a reckoning at the end of the plan.  The trustee files with the court a notice of final cure payment, alleging that all is well with the mortgage.

When the lender responds that the debtor isn’t current on the post filing payments, all hell breaks loose.

Too often, the court finds that the debtor’s failure to pay the ongoing mortgage payments is a material breach of the plan.  Because the plan hasn’t been fully performed, the case gets closed without a discharge.

Presumably, foreclosure follows, or another Chapter 13 filing.

Why Chapter 13’s are dismissed

In the debtor’s mind, it’s easy to see the on going payments as something just between the borrower and the lender.  If the lender isn’t happy, it can ask for relief from stay.

But the bankruptcy system sees it differently.

Since the debtor proposed the terms of the Chapter 13 plan, there’s a logic in sanctioning the debtor if he doesn’t do as he proposed to do.

The court would certainly sanction creditors if they didn’t honor the plan.

Consequences of dismissal

Dismissal without a discharge means that none of your debts is wiped out at the end of the plan.

Sometimes, that’s OK, if you’ve managed through the plan to pay taxes or your car loan.

But more often, it means that your personal obligation on the home loan lives on, along with any of the unsecured debt like credit cards, pay day loans, and medical bills survive as legally enforceable debts.

If you stripped off an underwater mortgage or avoided a judgment lien in the Chapter 13, you lose those benefits.

Preserving your bankruptcy discharge

The trick to getting your discharge is simple:  speak up.

Talk to your attorney when you begin having trouble making the on-going mortgage payment.

Talk through whether the problem is temporary or the inevitable consequence of too little income or intervening circumstances.

There are fixes.

  • You can modify your plan to terms you can live with as long as you are within the five year duration of a plan.
  • Maybe you surrender the house.
  • Maybe you reduce the plan payment til you catch up on the mortgage.
  • Maybe you dismiss this case and refile again to include the new arrears in a new plan.
  • Maybe converting to Chapter 7 works for you now.

But know that failing to address the issue puts the discharge at risk.  Chances are, you have too much at stake to keep quiet.

More

When a Chapter 13 falters

Why Chapter 13 plans fail

Can you change lawyers mid case?

Bankruptcy terms simplified

Is Home Equity A Substitute For Retirement Savings

By

My house is my retirement plan.

If I had a dollar for every time a client said that, I could retire today.

But that approach to funding your old age only works if….

Sell your house to retire

The value in your house makes your balance sheet strong, but doesn’t put food on the table or gas in the car.

That home equity is illiquid.  You can’t write a check against it for the other necessities of life.

To get at that equity, you need to sell the house, or  borrow against it.

A traditional loan requires that you have cash to cover the monthly loan payments.  But hey, you’re not working.  Where does that money come from?

Reverse mortgage

The reverse mortgage was invented to allow seniors who can’t make monthly payments on a conventional loan to access the equity in their home.

But the fact that a reverse mortgage has no monthly payments does not mean that it’s cost free.

No, the interest on the money borrowed accumulates over the life of the borrower.  And the unpaid interest itself earns interest.  The cost is steep.

Dangers in reverse mortgages

Reverse mortgages top list of older consumer complaints

And a condition of a reverse mortgage is that you keep up insurance and property taxes.

Real property has carrying costs

Whether encumbered or owned free and clear, real property has its own set of expenses.

  • Hazard insurance,
  • property taxes,
  • repair and upkeep.

Gotta have cash for those things.  The average Social Security check is about $1300.

Where do you live if you sell

If you’ve benefited from rising home values over your lifetime as a homeowner, the cost to replace the house you’re selling has risen as well.

And buying less house in your community still has the carrying costs we talked about above.

Or you rent.  So housing still has a cost.

Or you move out of the community you live in to somewhere where your sale proceeds go further.

You move away from friends and support systems.  Or maybe you move back to somewhere where you have a support system.  It can work both ways.

Taxes shrink your equity

Capital gain taxes are triggered if you sell your home.  Current tax law excludes from taxable income $250,000 in gain for a single person and $500,000 for a married couple. (Watch for changes, here).

So taxation will deplete your sales proceeds only if you have experienced a lot of appreciation over your lifetime.

But if you’re sitting on lots and lots of equity, count on it shrinking if you sell.

Don’t hide behind your house

There are no easy or universal answers here.  Our lives are longer and our preparation for old age is woefully incomplete.

For too many people I meet, the “home is my retirement account” is an excuse for overpaying for housing at the expense of retirement savings.  It provides cover for failure to set aside any money now.

Diversification of your retirement assets is clearly best.  Have cash and home equity as you age.

But however you are situated, give some clear thought as to how you fund those decades of life when you aren’t working.

More

Do California seniors need bankruptcy

What it costs to retire here

California homestead and senior debt

Image © Fotolia

Bankruptcy Debtors Entitled To Monthly Mortgage Statements

By

monthly mortgage statement

Years of uncertainty and indifference, rooted in the automatic stay and a homeowner’s ongoing obligation on their mortgage after bankruptcy, has ended with a new rule.

Mortgage servicers must now send monthly statements to borrowers in bankruptcy under a new CFPB rule effective April, 2018.   

The earlier version of the rule, adopted in 2014, allowed servicers to send no statements to consumers who had discharged their personal liability in bankruptcy or who had a pending bankruptcy case.

Now the rule creates a duty to render a monthly statement unless

  • the consumer requests the servicer stop sending statements
  • the consumer’s Chapter 13 plan provides for surrender, avoidance of the lien, or doesn’t provide for ongoing payments
  • a court order avoids the mortgage lien
  • a Chapter 7 statement of intentions indicates surrender AND no payment has been made since bankruptcy was filed

Even if an exemption to the duty applies, the consumer can opt in to receiving monthly statements by making a written request.  The request can be made by any borrower on the loan or by their agent, such as their bankruptcy attorney.

And just like RESPA Requests for Information, the servicer can designate an exclusive address to which the request must be made.

Statements tailored for Chapter 13

When a borrower is in Chapter 13, the servicer must modify the monthly statement to show the amount due as only the post petition amount.

The monthly statement must also account for the pre bankruptcy arrearages in a new category on the statement.  Required information on the arrears includes

  • amount received on the prepetition arrearage since the last statement
  • the total of all payments received since the bankruptcy was filed
  • the current balance of the prepetition arrearage

Boon to borrowers

This rule is a huge step forward for borrowers in bankruptcy.  Until this rule, there was a terrible disconnect between the borrower’s intention to continue paying on the mortgage and the servicer’s ability to avoid providing information about what is due.

FRBP 3002.1 spoke to part of the problem when it required servicers to file and serve notices of changes.  But that still left the homeowner without the monthly cue on where and how much to pay on the home loan. 

When mortgage lender changes their tune, it’s war.

The new rule goes a step further in that it requires the monthly statement to show both the state of the loan payments since bankruptcy, but also the progress toward curing any pre bankruptcy default.

Challenge to servicers

For the last 25 years of my bankruptcy practice, servicers have routinely botched the problem of accounting for payments made on mortgage loans in Chapter 13.  They have struggled to impliment a system that properly credits and accounts for payments received after filing on the continuing mortgage along side payments received on the pre bankruptcy arrears.

Even before this rule, servicers can seldom file papers with the bankruptcy court with numbers that are consistent as to the amount the debtor owes.  I’ve seen cases where a proof of claim, an objection to confirmation, and a motion for relief from stay from a lender each states a different number.

The chances for the servicer to screw up have just increased with the implementation of this rule.

I recognize that Chapter 13 presents a challenge, but servicers are in the business of accounting for money.  They need to get it right.  And if compliance makes their job more expensive, they can negotiate an increase in price for their services.

It can no longer be OK to keep borrowers who want to pay in the dark.

Thank you, CFPB.

More for borrowers

The new, improved Request for Information

Decoding your mortgage statement

Home Remedies For Foreclosure Breed Bankruptcy Tragedies

By

Warning: virulent outbreak of do-it-yourself bankruptcies all around.

Symptoms:  panic over prospect of foreclosure

Supposed remedy:  file your own skeleton Chapter 13 bankruptcy

Prognosis: enjoy the stay for about 2 weeks, followed by foreclosure relapse

Homeowners facing foreclosure

Three different would-be clients called in a 10 day period this month, facing foreclosure.  And all three had the same tragic, but avoidable story.

I was on the trail of an epidemic.

Each had filed an emergency bankruptcy petition to address a looming foreclosure.  They then did nothing to file the balance of the schedules necessary in their cases.

How dismissal differs from discharge

Without schedules,  the case was dismissed, automatically. No court hearing, just tossed out for failure to follow the order that says “you’ve got two weeks to file the rest of the papers”.

And they did the same thing all over again a little bit later, again filing only the bare minimum of paperwork, before the second case is dismissed.

With two cases dismissed in the past 12 months, there will be no automatic stay in a third case.  The  bankruptcy won’t prevent the lender from foreclosing.

As a bankruptcy attorney, my bag of remedies was essentially empty.

Why homeowners sucked in

I understand the appeal of the automatic stay: it’s a lynch-pin of bankruptcy relief.

The automatic stay is powerful:  it applies to all creditors, it makes actions in violation of the stay void, and it becomes effective instantly upon filing bankruptcy.

The necessary paperwork to initiate a case is minimal, and the filing fee is just over $300.

Pretty seductive if you are panicked about losing your home.

Multiple filings labeled abuse

The pattern of debtors filing, getting dismissed, and filing again irked lawmakers back when the last round of bankruptcy amendments passed Congress in 2005.

After “reform”, every debtor gets a stay in their case.

File a second case within 12 months after the first was dismissed, and the stay lasts only 30 days.  The court will consider extending the stay if the debtor applies and gets an order within that 30 days.

File a third case, after two dismissals within 12 months, and there simply is no stay.

Chapter 13 can save your home

The tragedy in all of this is that Chapter 13 works, if you want more than just a two week stay.  Few problems that threaten foreclosure can be solved in two weeks.

How 13 can save your home

Understand that letting your case be dismissed cripples your  ability  to use bankruptcy in another case.

More

What should bankruptcy cost

How to interview a bankruptcy lawyer

Don’t wait til the day before foreclosure

Image courtesy of torange.biz.

643 Bair Island Road
Suite 403
Redwood City, CA 94063
Phone: (650) 694-4700

Categories