• Home
  • Bankruptcy in Brief
  • ABC’s of Bankruptcy
  • Considering Bankruptcy
  • True Stories
  • Chapter 13
  • Blog
  • About
  • TOC

Northern California Bankruptcy Lawyer

On The Bankruptcy Soapbox

The Soap Box
  • How bankruptcy works
  • Mortgage Matters
  • Consumer Rights
  • Newsworthy
  • You & Your Lawyer
  • Small Business
  • Family Law

Spotting The Mean In The Means Test

By Cathy Moran

means test

Just being a consumer is enough to put you on Congress’s bad side when it comes to bankruptcy.

How do I know?

I read the “reformed” bankruptcy code.

Only those individuals whose debts are primarily consumer debts have to prove that they aren’t abusing the bankruptcy laws.

The Bankruptcy Code attempts to exclude from its shelter those who “abuse” the system.  Abuse is equated with having “enough” money to pay your debts.

That’s “enough” money under the formula Congress wrote.

Only consumers are scrutinized

Only a debtor whose debts are “primarily consumer” debts is subject to this scrutiny. Others get a pass.

Those whose debts result from business failure or failure to pay their taxes are not subject to review for “abuse”, regardless of their ability to pay.

Those debts aren’t “consumer” debts for this purpose.

One’s ability to pay back some or all of business debts or, for Pete’s sake, pay your taxes, isn’t a gating factor for getting into bankruptcy.

Income no bar for failed business folks

The impact of the consumer/non consumer distinction came home to me as I interviewed a single man with a fine salary, yesterday.

He is exempt from the means test because his debt was incurred in business.

There is certainly a policy argument for making the consequences of business failure tolerable. That is, I think, a hallmark of the American business ethic, the acceptance of failure and the encouragement of trying again.

Now employed by others and enjoying a generous income, he doesn’t have to prove that he needs bankruptcy relief.

Free pass for unpaid taxes

The exclusion from the “can-pay” scrutiny for those who haven’t paid taxes seems to me to be harder to justify.

Our society isn’t stronger for a policy protecting those who haven’t paid their fair share of maintaining our infrastructure.  Why do we let someone who has, for whatever reason, shirked paying taxes waltz into bankruptcy without scrutiny, where the guy with medical bills or credit card debt has to justify his need for bankruptcy?

Which leads you back to the unstated premise underlying the means test:  consumers who can’t pay their bills are to some degree dishonest.

My learned opinion is HOGWASH.

More from the Soapbox

  • 4 Compelling Reasons To File The Tax Return Even If You Can’t Pay4 Compelling Reasons To File The Tax Return Even If You Can’t Pay
  • Disarm The Debt Collector: Understanding The Weapons of CollectionDisarm The Debt Collector: Understanding The Weapons of Collection
  • Make Sure Your Mortgage Is Current At Bankruptcy’s EndMake Sure Your Mortgage Is Current At Bankruptcy’s End
  • Tax Tips & Tidbits To Pay LessTax Tips & Tidbits To Pay Less
  • Scammers Spoof IRS To Get Your InfoScammers Spoof IRS To Get Your Info

Filed Under: Featured, True Stories Tagged With: 2016

About Cathy Moran

I'm a veteran bankruptcy lawyer and consumer advocate in California's Silicon Valley. I write, teach, and speak in the hopes of expanding understanding of how bankruptcy can make life better in a family's future.

Chapter 13 available to more

About The Soapbox

You've arrived at the Bankruptcy Soapbox, a resource of bankruptcy information and consumer law.

Soapbox is a companion site to Bankruptcy in Brief, where I try to be largely explanatory and even handed (Note I said "try").

Here, I allow myself to tell stories and express strong opinions on how I think law should work for the consumer and small businesses when it comes to debt.

Moran Law Group
Bankruptcy specialists for individuals and small businesses in the San Francisco Bay Area

How Bankruptcy Works

What You Left Out Of Your Bankruptcy Schedules

One of the first questions a bankruptcy trustee will ask you at the hearing in your bankruptcy case is:  did you read the schedules before you signed them? The obvious, and expected, answer is YES. And if your answer is "yes", then the trustee can conclude that you stand behind the information that the … Read more

More Posts from this Category

643 Bair Island Road
Suite 403
Redwood City, CA 94063
Phone: (650) 694-4700
Phone: (650) 368-4700

Categories

All content copyright © Moran Law Group. All rights reserved.