• Home
  • Bankruptcy in Brief
  • ABC’s of Bankruptcy
  • Considering Bankruptcy
  • True Stories
  • Chapter 13
  • Blog
  • About
  • TOC

Northern California Bankruptcy Lawyer

On The Bankruptcy Soapbox

The Soap Box
  • How bankruptcy works
  • Mortgage Matters
  • Consumer Rights
  • You & Your Lawyer
  • Small Business
  • Family Law

Oakland Bankruptcy Judge Upheld At 9th Circuit

By Cathy Moran

Tax agency runs out of timeRuling against the California Franchise Tax Board, the 9th Circuit upheld Oakland bankruptcy judge Edward Jellen’s decision in the Chapter 13 case of Brenda Marie Jones.

At issue was whether Jones could discharge a state tax debt in her Chapter 7 case; the question turned on an arcane question of what the Bankruptcy Code means when it provides that property “vest” in the debtor at plan confirmation.

If the automatic stay continued in effect after confirmation in Ms. Jones’ prior Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the FTB’s claim in her subsequent case was protected from discharge. If, however, vesting terminated the protection for her property provided by bankruptcy law, sufficient time had run to make the tax claim dischargeable.

The Court of Appeals noted that there are four different legal theories about what it means for property to “vest” in a Chapter 13 case. While declining to decide directly which of those four approaches was correct, the 9th Circuit panel held that some property of the estate vested in the debtor at confirmation and therefore the clock started ticking on the FTB’s window for collecting the tax. That window closed before Ms. Jones filed her new Chapter 7, and the tax was thus old enough to be eliminated in bankruptcy.

I’ve been following and speaking on this issue of vesting for a couple of years. I had hopes that this circuit would choose sides and provide some guidance to bankruptcy practitioners. It’s frustrating that presented with an opportunity to affirm the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel’s analysis that the estate terminates at vesting, the circuit court ducked. But their decision came to the same place the BAP was: a post petition creditor is free to collect its claim against the debtor following the vesting of the property of the estate at confirmation of a Chapter 13 plan.

More from the Soapbox

  • California’s Good Deed:  Passing Real Property At DeathCalifornia’s Good Deed: Passing Real Property At Death
  • Warning: Wells Fargo Can Freeze Your AccountWarning: Wells Fargo Can Freeze Your Account
  • Cheapskate’s Guide To Asset ProtectionCheapskate’s Guide To Asset Protection
  • “Chapter 20” Lives in Northern California Bankruptcy Courts“Chapter 20” Lives in Northern California Bankruptcy Courts
  • Pay Off Credit Cards At Zero PercentPay Off Credit Cards At Zero Percent

Filed Under: Developing law

About Cathy Moran

I'm a veteran bankruptcy lawyer and consumer advocate in California's Silicon Valley. I write, teach, and speak in the hopes of expanding understanding of how bankruptcy can make life better in a family's future.

Bankruptcy Basics

About The Soapbox

You’ve arrived at the Bankruptcy Soapbox, a resource of bankruptcy information and consumer law.

Soapbox is a companion site to Bankruptcy in Brief, where I try to be largely explanatory and even handed (Note I said “try”).

Here, I allow myself to tell stories and express strong opinions. We dig deeper into how to consider bankruptcy and navigate a bankruptcy case.

Moran Law Group
Bankruptcy specialists for individuals and small businesses in the San Francisco Bay Area

How Bankruptcy Works

What Happens To Your Bank Account in Chapter 13

Those considering filing a Chapter 13 bankruptcy worry about "what happens to my bank account?" Will the trustee take all the money? How do I pay my living expenses after I file? The short answer is: nothing changes. The account remains yours and available for all the expenses of day to day living. Because, … Read more

More Posts from this Category

643 Bair Island Road
Suite 403
Redwood City, CA 94063
Phone: (650) 694-4700
Phone: (650) 368-4700

Categories

All content copyright © Moran Law Group. All rights reserved.