Sued For Debt? Don’t Bother To Tell It To The Judge


The New York Times’ great feature on the dark world of consumer debt collection had a marvelous flow chart of the progress of collecting an old bill.

Only it was deceptively wrong.

After following the debt collector’s options and outcomes from first collection call to the various resolutions, the graphic showed two wildly different outcomes if the consumer got sued.

One outcome had the consumer telling the judge, “I’ve fallen on hard times and can’t afford to pay my debt“.  Result:  the consumer loses.  Hard times isn’t a legal defense to a collection suit.

The second outcome had the consumer telling the judge:  “Make them prove I owe the money“.  Result, says the article:  the consumer wins!

Why the different results for different scripts?  Because, the debt buyer has no proof of the debt.  And the burden of proof in a collection suit lies with the person who filed the suit.

Lawsuits require proof

When the collector bought the old account from the original creditor, or an intermediate collector, no supporting documents came with it.  The debt buyer got just a spreadsheet with the consumer’s name, account number, and amount due.  He has no proof that you owe the debt and no proof that the debt is still enforceable.

No proof, no judgment.

But that little lesson in legal procedure is not the point I want to make here.  My point is telling it to the judge at trial gets you nothing if you haven’t raised the issue in a written answer.

Courts rely on the written word

Courts move on the basis of paper.  More particularly, courts act on written pleadings filed with the court clerk and served on the other side to the lawsuit.

If you haven’t filed an answer in the lawsuit, nothing you say to the judge will change the outcome.

Now, on the odd occasion, a judge may consider arguments made for the first time in a courtroom.  It happens just often enough to make me cautious about saying “never”.  But don’t count on it.

If disputing the debt is worth your time showing up at court, then it’s worth filing an answer in your defense.

Don’t think you can simply arrive in court and win on the basis of clever words at trial.

File an answer

Getting an answer on file can be a problem if you don’t have money for a lawyer.  I’ve got that.

You can do it yourself.

Lots of courts these days have pro per help desks where you can get guidance on participating in a lawsuit.  The California courts maintain an online legal self help site.   Here are links to  Bay Area court’s pro per resources:

Santa Clara County 

San Mateo County

Alameda County

Santa Cruz County

Check out the available resources in your area to help you file the right paper so you can defend yourself in court.

Image courtesy of Flickr and Penn State.


How Voodoo Economics Curses Your Budget

  I can’t save anything because it takes every dollar I make just to get by. Sound like a description of your budget? For some folks, that is absolutely true. But for another slice of working folks, there’s some black magic budgeting going on that hides what’s really afoot. These voodoo budgets look rational, but only on…

We Don’t Arrest People For Not Paying Debts

This fake arrest warrant is wrong in so many ways. Repeat after me: we don’t jail people for debt. More on scams and scammers We’re from the IRS and we’re here to help Phone tip to avoid arrest

Dividing Debts At Divorce: What You Need To Know

The division of the debts of a failed marriage, however carefully crafted at divorce, can be utterly destroyed if one of the former spouses files a Chapter 13 bankruptcy. A Chapter 13 discharge is double barreled.  It will eliminate the debts that the filing spouse owes to creditors.  It also wipes out any obligation to the…

Four Factors Drive What You Should Pay For Bankruptcy

When you’re flat broke and thinking about bankruptcy, cheaper sure looks better. If a lawyer will do your Chapter 7 for $600, what’s the point of paying $1000? Or even $2000? Like answers to many legal questions, it depends. Bankruptcy relief depends on your facts Whether to file bankruptcy, or whether to file now, rather than later,…

How To Wipe Out Tax Penalties In Bankruptcy

Tax penalties seem like a further insult when you’re having trouble paying the tax itself. Everything seems subject to an additional penalty:  failure to file timely;  failure to pre pay sufficiently;  failure to be accurate. They mount up quickly, often equaling the unpaid tax. Bankruptcy can not only eliminate your liability for certain taxes, it…

How To Keep Your Money Away From The Bankruptcy Trustee, Legally

Getting a check from the government isn’t necessarily a great thing. Not when it’s the government returning YOUR money as a tax refund.  You’ve struggled without the money for a year while Uncle Sam used it without interest. But it’s even worse when you’ve filed bankruptcy during the tax year, and come April, the bankruptcy…

Debts To The Government: Can They Be Wiped Out

It’s easy to assume that debts owed to the federal government can’t be discharged in bankruptcy. Easy, but wrong. Just because the creditor is Uncle Sam doesn’t mean the debt can’t be wiped out in bankruptcy. In fact, debts to the government range from freely dischargeable to not-in-this-lifetime nondischargeable. Honesty required for discharge To be…

8 Essential Tasks To Maximize Your Bankruptcy Fresh Start

 Got your bankruptcy discharge?   The end of the bankruptcy case is the start of your new financial life. Now, you’ve got work to do to maximize that fresh start. Save your bankruptcy papers The bankruptcy schedules listed everyone you owed money to when you filed.  Those creditors got notice of your case. The discharge…

How Californians Can Leave A Legacy, Despite Debts

Unbalanced_scales wikimedia public domain

Seniors in California enjoy stout protections against collection actions by their creditors. Those protections often make it unnecessary for a debt laden senior to file bankruptcy. But no one talks about one consequence of relying on exemption law to fend off creditors. California exemption laws that  fully protect the assets of seniors provide no protection to the heirs….